preview

Women in Development vs. Gender and Development Essay

Better Essays

Most of the people who inhabit this world live in poverty. However, women are more likely than men to be impoverished. This is called the feminization of poverty.[1] In the 1970s, feminists and agents of development came up with an approach to address this problem called the Women in Development [WID] approach. As the years went by, this approach was criticized. A new approach emerged out of this critique called Gender and Development [GAD] approach. This paper makes two arguments: that GAD is the best approach to address the inequalities women experience in developing countries, and that the WID approach must also play a supportive role in addressing these inequalities. A crucial difference between the GAD approach and the …show more content…

The WID approach focuses on women’s ‘practical gender needs’. These are the needs women have that are specific to their gendered roles in society.[9] For instance, if it is a women’s gendered role to care for children, then examples of practical gender needs would be education, daycare, and nutritional supplements for infants and small children. Overall, practical gender needs address a woman’s immediate material survival and ease the burden of her gendered responsibilities. However, they “do not challenge the gender division of labour or a women’s subordinate position in society…”[10] The GAD approach, however, by focussing on women’s ‘strategic gender needs’, does challenge both these things. Strategic gender needs encompass a diverse range of issues, from economic issues such as the pay-gap between men and women, to gender role issues such as the domestic division of labour, and even issues not traditionally associated with development, such as violence against women.[11] At the root of all these issues is patriarchy, and thus, the dismantling of patriarchy is the aim of strategic gender needs. Although practical gender needs and strategic gender needs both have their merit, problems arise if development policies focus exclusively on practical gender needs. If women’s strategic gender needs are not also addressed, the benefits gained by addressing

Get Access