Figure attached, you don't need any of the textbook words to figure out the answer so don't worry about the font size.  A student in a course on intelligent design theory claims that the graph in part (a) shows that losing the ability to respire actually is adaptive for yeast cells living in small populations.  Please read the incomplete sentence that appears immediately below, assess as possible completions the lowercase-Roman-numeral-labelled statements that follow, and click each uppercase-letter-labelled response that is presented below and completes accurately the sentence. An astute student in an evolution course would respond that i. the graph in part (a) shows that selection among mitochondria within yeast cells can lead to fixation for traits that decrease mean fitness for that yeast population. ii. the student in the course on intelligent design is wrong; the yeast cells in the small population group retained completely the ability to respire, as they otherwise would have been unable to harvest energy. iii. a property (e.g., inability to respire) that is maladaptive for individuals (e.g., unicellular organisms that are characterised by possessing the trait with that property) may be driven to fixation by selection operating at a different level (e.g., on organelles, like mitochondria).

Biology (MindTap Course List)
11th Edition
ISBN:9781337392938
Author:Eldra Solomon, Charles Martin, Diana W. Martin, Linda R. Berg
Publisher:Eldra Solomon, Charles Martin, Diana W. Martin, Linda R. Berg
Chapter1: A View Of Life
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 14TYU: INTERPRET DATA Compare the two graphs in Figure 1-17. What information does the second graph...
icon
Related questions
Question

Figure attached, you don't need any of the textbook words to figure out the answer so don't worry about the font size. 

A student in a course on intelligent design theory claims that the graph in part (a) shows that losing the ability to respire actually is adaptive for yeast cells living in small populations.  Please read the incomplete sentence that appears immediately below, assess as possible completions the lowercase-Roman-numeral-labelled statements that follow, and click each uppercase-letter-labelled response that is presented below and completes accurately the sentence.

An astute student in an evolution course would respond that

i. the graph in part (a) shows that selection among mitochondria within yeast cells can lead to fixation for traits that decrease mean fitness for that yeast population.

ii. the student in the course on intelligent design is wrong; the yeast cells in the small population group retained completely the ability to respire, as they otherwise would have been unable to harvest energy.

iii. a property (e.g., inability to respire) that is maladaptive for individuals (e.g., unicellular organisms that are characterised by possessing the trait with that property) may be driven to fixation by selection operating at a different level (e.g., on organelles, like mitochondria).

 

Question 7 options:

 

A) 

Statement ii conveys accurate information.

 

B) 

Statements i, ii, and iii convey accurate information.

 

C) 

Statements i and ii convey accurate information.

 

D) 

Statements i and iii convey accurate information.

 

E) 

Statements ii and iii convey accurate information.

remained at intermediate levels.
This experiment demonstrates that when selection among yeast cells is rela-
tively weak, selection among mitochondria within yeast cells can lead to the
fixation of traits that decrease the mean fitness of the yeast population. Had we
not recognized that selection acts on different levels, we might have mistakenly
(a)
Frequency
10
Small
(10 cells)
Frequency after 150 generations
of yeast cells containing only
parasitic mitochondria
Medium
(250 cells)
--
Large
(18,000 cells)
(b)
Figure 10.32 Selection at the level of cells in popula-
tions versus selection at the level of mitochondria inside
cells (a) Each bar represents the average of five experimental
populations started with yeast cells containing a mixture of
normal versus parasitic mitochondria. Among mitochondrial
within yeast cells, selection favors parasites, because they
replicate faster. This selective advantage was constant across
Frequency
Cell population size
Frequency after 150 generations
of yeast cells containing only
chloramphenicol-susceptible mitochondria
Small
(10 cells)
Medium
(250 cells)
Large
(18,000 cells)
selective advantage varies among yeast cultures maintained at
different population sizes; it is weakest in small populations
and strongest in large populations. Parasitic mitochondria
thrive in small yeast populations but fall to low frequency in
large yeast populations. (b) Each bar represents the average
of four or five control populations started with yeast cells
containing a mixture of chloramphenicol-resistant versus
Transcribed Image Text:remained at intermediate levels. This experiment demonstrates that when selection among yeast cells is rela- tively weak, selection among mitochondria within yeast cells can lead to the fixation of traits that decrease the mean fitness of the yeast population. Had we not recognized that selection acts on different levels, we might have mistakenly (a) Frequency 10 Small (10 cells) Frequency after 150 generations of yeast cells containing only parasitic mitochondria Medium (250 cells) -- Large (18,000 cells) (b) Figure 10.32 Selection at the level of cells in popula- tions versus selection at the level of mitochondria inside cells (a) Each bar represents the average of five experimental populations started with yeast cells containing a mixture of normal versus parasitic mitochondria. Among mitochondrial within yeast cells, selection favors parasites, because they replicate faster. This selective advantage was constant across Frequency Cell population size Frequency after 150 generations of yeast cells containing only chloramphenicol-susceptible mitochondria Small (10 cells) Medium (250 cells) Large (18,000 cells) selective advantage varies among yeast cultures maintained at different population sizes; it is weakest in small populations and strongest in large populations. Parasitic mitochondria thrive in small yeast populations but fall to low frequency in large yeast populations. (b) Each bar represents the average of four or five control populations started with yeast cells containing a mixture of chloramphenicol-resistant versus
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Prokaryotic evolution
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, biology and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Biology (MindTap Course List)
Biology (MindTap Course List)
Biology
ISBN:
9781337392938
Author:
Eldra Solomon, Charles Martin, Diana W. Martin, Linda R. Berg
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Biology: The Dynamic Science (MindTap Course List)
Biology: The Dynamic Science (MindTap Course List)
Biology
ISBN:
9781305389892
Author:
Peter J. Russell, Paul E. Hertz, Beverly McMillan
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Human Heredity: Principles and Issues (MindTap Co…
Human Heredity: Principles and Issues (MindTap Co…
Biology
ISBN:
9781305251052
Author:
Michael Cummings
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Biology 2e
Biology 2e
Biology
ISBN:
9781947172517
Author:
Matthew Douglas, Jung Choi, Mary Ann Clark
Publisher:
OpenStax
Biology Today and Tomorrow without Physiology (Mi…
Biology Today and Tomorrow without Physiology (Mi…
Biology
ISBN:
9781305117396
Author:
Cecie Starr, Christine Evers, Lisa Starr
Publisher:
Cengage Learning