Model 3: Stability of Resonance Forms Not all resonance forms have the same energy; some forms may be more stable than others. The major resonance contributor is determined by the following factors (where 1 is more Important and 5 is less important): 1. complete octet 2. as many bonds as possible 3. no charge on individual atoms 4. if charges exist, then negative charge resides on more electronegative atom, or positive charge resides on less electronegative atom 5. if charges exist, then small charge separation between charged atoms :0: R 7 H. Questions: 8. For the resonance forms shown in Model 3: (a) Circle any atoms in Model 3 that do not have complete octets. (b) Indicate the total number of bonds for each structure shown in Model 3. (c) Which structure has no charges on any individual atoms? (d) If charges exist, which atom is most likely to hold the negative charge? (C, H, or O) Based on the rules in Model 3, which structure would be the major contributor? Explain. (e) 9. Add curved arrows to show the conversion of 78 and 8 → 9 in Model 3. 10. For the following structure, use curved arrows to draw three additional resonance structures and predict which form, if any, would be the major contributor. (HINT: move double bond or lone pair electrons only and try moving one pair at a time). H R H 8 H

Organic Chemistry: A Guided Inquiry
2nd Edition
ISBN:9780618974122
Author:Andrei Straumanis
Publisher:Andrei Straumanis
Chapter5: Resonance
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 28CTQ
icon
Related questions
icon
Concept explainers
Question
Model 3: Stability of Resonance Forms
Not all resonance forms have the same energy; some forms may be more stable than others.
The major resonance contributor is determined by the following factors (where 1 is more
Important and 5 is less important):
1. complete octet
2. as many bonds as possible
3. no charge on individual atoms
4. if charges exist, then negative charge resides on more electronegative atom, or positive
charge resides on less electronegative atom
5. if charges exist, then small charge separation between charged atoms
:0:
R
7
R
H
+
Questions:
8. For the resonance forms shown in Model 3:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
8
H
H
gh
H
H
R
Circle any atoms in Model 3 that do not have complete octets.
Indicate the total number of bonds for each structure shown in Model 3.
9
Which structure has no charges on any individual atoms?
If charges exist, which atom is most likely to hold the negative charge? (C, H, or O)
Based on the rules in Model 3, which structure would be the major contributor? Explain.
9. Add curved arrows to show the conversion of 7-8 and 8 → 9 in Model 3.
10. For the following structure, use curved arrows to draw three additional resonance structures
and predict which form, if any, would be the major contributor. (HINT: move double bond or
lone pair electrons only and try moving one pair at a time).
POGIL
www.FOGEL.ORG
Coppg' © 2015
Reflection: on a separate sheet of paper.
As a group, describe three concepts your group has learned from this activity and the one most
important unanswered question about this activity that remains with your group. Turn this in
before leaving class.
Transcribed Image Text:Model 3: Stability of Resonance Forms Not all resonance forms have the same energy; some forms may be more stable than others. The major resonance contributor is determined by the following factors (where 1 is more Important and 5 is less important): 1. complete octet 2. as many bonds as possible 3. no charge on individual atoms 4. if charges exist, then negative charge resides on more electronegative atom, or positive charge resides on less electronegative atom 5. if charges exist, then small charge separation between charged atoms :0: R 7 R H + Questions: 8. For the resonance forms shown in Model 3: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) 8 H H gh H H R Circle any atoms in Model 3 that do not have complete octets. Indicate the total number of bonds for each structure shown in Model 3. 9 Which structure has no charges on any individual atoms? If charges exist, which atom is most likely to hold the negative charge? (C, H, or O) Based on the rules in Model 3, which structure would be the major contributor? Explain. 9. Add curved arrows to show the conversion of 7-8 and 8 → 9 in Model 3. 10. For the following structure, use curved arrows to draw three additional resonance structures and predict which form, if any, would be the major contributor. (HINT: move double bond or lone pair electrons only and try moving one pair at a time). POGIL www.FOGEL.ORG Coppg' © 2015 Reflection: on a separate sheet of paper. As a group, describe three concepts your group has learned from this activity and the one most important unanswered question about this activity that remains with your group. Turn this in before leaving class.
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 4 steps with 3 images

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Electronic Effects
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, chemistry and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Organic Chemistry: A Guided Inquiry
Organic Chemistry: A Guided Inquiry
Chemistry
ISBN:
9780618974122
Author:
Andrei Straumanis
Publisher:
Cengage Learning