Alienation in Modern Society
I will compare and contrast Mike Newell's Dance with a Stranger and Danny Boyle's Shallow Grave in terms of alienation. The reasoning behind my choice is that these two films have explicit characteristics in the frame of alienation. Both highlight modern alienation in terms of alienated sexuality, isolation, normlessness whereas Newell discusses alienation also in class and gender difference perspective; Boyle discusses alienation in the working place as an alienated labour.
To begin with, when we examine Dance with a Stranger, we see Ruth, David, Desmond and Andy as film's main characters. Ruth is the most alienated character in this film. Firstly, she was a manager of a night club, she was taking care
…show more content…
Dancing requires paying attention to your partner, however Ruth failed to do this, she couldn't overcome her desires and create self-sustain bounds. So these failures of her, lead to social alienation in modern society.
Yet another means, the visual elements of Dance with a Stranger displays specific lighting techniques to clarify the ambiguity about the characters behavior and relationships. In the foggy scene, everything is in dark; there is incapability of seeing the whole. This emphasizes the uncertainty in the world by means of alienation problem, lack of understanding the whole. Soon after foggy scene, sequence goes on in darkness, just two characters in shots and there is no other people around them their relationship alienated from society's regular relationships. there is impossibility of clear vision which points out our perspective is limited to see and give meanings to all the things which are going on in our social world, this brings meaninglessness likewise alienation.
Similarly, Danny Boyle's Shallow Grave has alienated characters in modern society. David*, Juliet and Alex are the main characters of the film. After having cut the dead body of the forth roommate, David* began to behave strange. He isolated himself from others and moved to loft. He escaped from his social responsibilities and didn't go to his workplace. He realized that how he could be violent, he feels insecurity because the modern life seemed unpredictable
The second form of alienation was alienating the worker from working. The worker was also alienated from himself as the key producer or from his “species being”. The worker is estranged
Ruth’s dream is to improve her family’s lifestyle and move into a house where she can raise Travis and the new baby. To realize her dreams she should not put everyone else’s wants and needs in front of hers all of the time. She should express her feelings more often so that her family will listen and help her to reach her goals. The play supports this view by showing how Ruth often neglects her feelings and pays great attention to her family’s feelings, wants, and needs.
The movie “Breaking Away” presents the story of a young man from working class origins who seeks to better himself by creating a persona through which he almost, but not quite, wins the girl. The rivalry between the townies and the college students sets the scene for the story of four friends who learn to accept themselves as they "break away" from childhood and from their underdog self-images.
Further on in the book I has read how Nora was going to be the entertainment of the party. In act two in the play Nora was too that she was going to be the special entertainment to the party dancing. Normally today when parties are hosted by a family they are hosted as a husband and wife together. Nora was not considered a hostess with the husband, just the dancer. This is yet another
Alienation is something we find to be constantly present within our society. This idea is steadily exemplified throughout history whether it be through class, race, or any social unjust. In Kristen Dombek’s piece, she details various accounts of social alienation. The reader follows as Dombek reveals corruption between human relationships and the way we interact with world. She exposes what we are all afraid to admit- modern values and morals. Kristen Dombek presses us with the question of why we do the things we do and live the way we live. Readers are forced to question if they are slaves to the world around them. Do we succumb to the social and economical pressure demanded from us, and if so, will we allow that to happen for the generations after us? Although alienation is something that roots from ourselves as individuals, recognize the factors in our lives that this originates from. Question the relationships people have established in their own neighborhood, or if a prosaic office job is fulfilling. When we serve our economy but it does not do the same for us, the symbiosis or harmony in which live in is disrupted. Will we make a change for the beauty we desire to create and the life we lead in oppression today or tomorrow? In Bank-robbin in Brooklyn Kristen Dombeck explores the ideas of societal alienation by questioning the dynamic of people 's’ lives in their neighborhoods, in the workplace and their roles in society in general.
Another factor that influences my interpretation of Ruth, is economics. Nadar’s interpretation of Ruth is that she is a survivor and a positive role model for underprivileged women and widowers. I do not disagree that she is a survivor, but I do believe Ruth was exploited by working the land and becoming the reproductive means for Boaz and Naomi’s economic profit. Yee talks about Ruth’s desperate act of trying to have sex with Boaz as a way to lock him down for economic security. She states “Whether or not Ruth and Boaz had sex that fateful night should not distract us from the economic urgency that compelled Ruth the foreigner to go to the threshing floor in the first place,” (20). Yee and I completely agree with Katherine Sakenfeld when she states “No woman should have to do something so socially unacceptable in Israelite culture… in order to put food on her family’s table for the longer term. This is not a slightly adventurous tryst. It is a desperate act by a desperate person,”
She had to endure people’s prejudice against Jews, working in her family’s store, and sexual abuse from her father. There was no family life for the Shilsky’s, just working in the store. During that time, she was ashamed because they were poor, Jewish, and her mom was handicapped (from the polio she had). Of course, this would change during her time in Suffolk, but only her family’s economic status would change. As she said, “[…] had plenty of money and we were all miserable” (61). Her older brother Sam, couldn’t take all the pressure and ran away from home and later died in WW2 in a plane crash. Luckily, Ruth did have one friend. Her name was Frances and Ruth was always welcome at Frances’ house. She didn’t care that Ruth was Jewish and with Frances around, Ruth wasn’t bullied (it was a different story when Frances wasn’t there). Ruth soon sets the reader up for what happens next by telling the audience “If there was one thing Tateh didn’t like more than gentiles it was black folks” (107), with Tateh being Ruth’s father. Then she talks about how her first boyfriend was a black teen named Peter and a few pages after introducing that, Ruth tells the reader that she was pregnant. What made it worse was that she was 15 and that she lived in the South where if a black person even looked at a white person the wrong way, there was going to be
While traveling to New York City, Victoria and her sister Tennessee met Cornelius Vanderbilt. He was appreciative of Victoria, so he helped them start the first women-run stock brokerage company. Along with her sister Tennessee, Victoria created a publication called Woodhull and Claflin’s Weekly. With the publication, the sisters were able to give their opinions on women’s suffrage, social reforms and other rights that they thought women deserve. She spoke out publically, and even appointed the issues to congress. Although she tried to raise more awareness by running for president, some of her supporters alienated because of her remarks about sexuality and social
the end of the film fixates the audience emotions from the film’s genre are manifested within
In the short story Killings by Andre Dubus, Ruth is portrayed as a secondary character. Since Ruth is the mother of Frank, it would seem evident that she would be involved in revenge. Ruth’s sadness over Frank’s death is Matt’s justification to pursue the killing, but she is never directly involved in Matt’s plot for revenge. In the film In the Bedroom by Todd Feel, Ruth’s character plays a much larger role in the overall story. She has substantial influence over the actions of the other characters in the story. When Ruth sees Richard in the market, she is so distraught by the event that she ends up influencing Matt’s decision to kill Richard. Ruth’s emotional presence is Matt’s justification to carry out with the killing, and her physical presence is even more impactful. When she is present, the reason that Matt develops a plan to kill Richard becomes more evident. Her emotions are straining her relationship with Matt, and he can not put her in the background. Matt feels that something must happen in order to mend Ruth’s emotional state, so he decides to take matters into his own hands.
Michael Granada Period 4 Summer Reading Assignment The Color of Water by James McBride I. Character Analysis – Ruth McBride a. “What color is God’s spirit?” “It doesn’t have a color,” she said. “God is the color of water. Water doesn’t have a color.”
Ruth is the catalyst for Grange to change his ways in his third life. After Grange's son, Brownfield kills his wife he is sent to jail, and his three children are orphaned. Grange takes the youngest child, Ruth, under his custody, while the older two are sent up north to live with their other grandfather. When Ruth comes into Granges life, he gains a whole new perspective on things. His priorities shift and Ruth becomes number one. His second wife, Josie doesn't understand this close bond that forms between grandfather and granddaughter or why Grange sees so much hope in Ruth.
Marx’s theory of alienation is concerned primarily with social interaction and production; he believes that we are able to overcome our alienation through human emancipation.
Topic: One of the essential elements to Marx’s alienation concept is that of people or workers being alienated from each other under capitalism, it is still relevant in explaining the problems of the modern world.
The theory of alienation developed by Karl Marx depicts the estrangement of people due to living in a capitalist system of production. Through the manuscript “Estranged Labor” from his Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, Marx describes his theory of alienation and specifies on the four types of ways in which the worker is alienated. A vivid example of Marx’s theory of alienation can be seen through Charlie Chaplin’s comedy film Modern Times. In his film, the central idea of the theory of labor alienation and how the worker is affected by the alienation are depicted. The notion of alienation depicted in Marx’s “Estranged Labor” is also depicted in Chaplin’s Modern Times.