preview

Analysis Of 'Some Garbage I Used To Believe About Equality'

Decent Essays

Check your privilege. If you're white, and a man, you're already a bigot. In the paper, “Some Garbage I Used To Believe About Equality” penned by Johnathan Nightingale, seemed to be a persuasive argument to get the intended audience, straight white males, to actively be less bigoted, and more understanding to other people’s problems. He mainly states this through a pathos filled journey of “you think you aren't a bigot”, leading on through meritocratic fallacy, and who could forget the classic, “so you don't think that was racist”. He offers little logos examples but a good placeholder to that would be his arguments through common sense. Some main arguments of this essay are flawed, but the overarching message is seemingly positive, and agreeable.

The author kicks off by trying to put himself on the same level of his intended audience, stating that he himself would be implementing the changes he argues for into his own life, just as we should to ours. The main message being to actively be less of an ass. The author uses inductive reasoning on his main argument, following along the lines of: You are white and a man, So you are privileged, So you are ignorant to the struggle of others, So you are a bigot. This line of reasoning is incredibly flawed and dare i say hypocritical, especially as the basis of the whole essay stemming from this assumption. The reason being the use of a generalization of an entire people to further a point about bigotry being negative.

“I know. You’re not a grotesque and evil bigot. You didn’t vote for Trump.” The purpose of this assumption is to inject pathos into the mix. He implies that even if you feel you aren't apart of his argument, you still play a role in bigotry. He goes on to justify this by offering the idea that “Being painted with an unfair, overgeneralized brush is something other folks deal with every damned day.” He implies that if you feel you are being painted with a broad brush, that that is what every other group of peoples has gone through, and probably worse, so it shouldn't matter. Although I agree with the words in the quote, this is a bad argument, showing that generalizations shouldn't matter if they happen to white people, because other non white

Get Access