preview

Arguments Against Circular Reasoning

Decent Essays

Logic, as most people know, is the art and science of reasoning well. Studied logicians use facts to craft clear, convincing arguments that support various positions. Correct arguments state reliable facts – or premises, as some call them – and then draw a conclusion based on those facts. Only a single error in an argument can bring the whole thing crashing down, which causes the debater to lose both the point and part of their reputability. Circular reasoning has become one fault that occurs far too often. Dictionary.com, which research shows as a reputable website, defines circular reasoning as “a use of reason in which the premises depends on or is equivalent to the conclusion, a method of false logic by which 'this is used to prove that, …show more content…

Perhaps, if you carefully inspect details of geology, archeologists can find select facts that line up with the ancient text. However, so little evidence exists that if one removed the Bible from the picture, then science would not point to a message such as the Bible presents. Anyone can find some obscure evidence to support a position, and those who uphold the Word of God's infallibility have done exactly that. They have found scraps of evidence that line up with what they seek to prove, but not so much that the evidence by itself overwhelmingly points to the Bible. Therefore, science may offer a tiny bit of support towards the Bible; however, it does not offer enough to prove the Bible, which negates the argument that science proves the Scriptures. With that argument out of the way, the remaining defenses for absolute Biblical truth rely on circular …show more content…

Unfortunately, it requires circular reasoning in order for the text to so prove itself. Since the unreliability of circular logic is obvious, it follows that the truth of the Bible cannot be trusted. So what? The basic faith of Christianity becomes unstable when the Word of God becomes untrustworthy. Entire lives will fall apart and hundreds of people will become unstable and confused, and all because they put faith in an unreliable document. Why does that matter to me?All humans instinctively know not to follow something that they cannot trust, but many refuse to obey these instincts when it comes to religion. People should begin to think and realize the foolhardiness of a conservative Christian faith that heavily relies on the infallibility of the Bible, for if the Bible cannot be trusted, then they have wasted their lives on a fool's errand. Whether a Creator exists or not, human lives clearly have worth, and people should not waste their short span of years in a mindless

Get Access