preview

Compare And Contrast Meditation 17 And The Human Condition

Decent Essays

We as humans have no real way of knowing our purpose on this world. One potential reasoning for human existence could be whether or not we were put here to congregate together, or to fend for ourselves. John Donne expresses in “Meditation 17” his belief in working together in mankind; whereas in Matthew Arnold’s poem, “To Marguerite – Continued” states that “We mortal enemies live alone.” Even though Donne’s theory would be most ideal to put belief in, I firmly believe in the idea that humans are alone in a sea of people. This concept has been written, sung, and painted about over the centuries. Giotto’s Crucifix, Renee Magritte’s The Human Condition, and Howard Nemerov’s “The Human Condition” all support their own idea of loneliness of each individual in a society. …show more content…

Each of these paintings portray the world which many of us see: empty and lonely. Both the painting from 1933 and 1935 show a canvas with the outside world painted with no human subjects. This potentially justifies Arnold’s interpretation of our existence, being that “we mortal millions live alone”. The probability that Magritte was inspired by Matthew Arnold is slim, but Magritte does inspire multiple works of seclusion. “The Human Condition”, by Howard Nemerov, is just one of the many writings inspired by Renee Magritte’s paintings. In this poem, Nemerov talks about being isolated in a room with Magritte’s The Human Condition. This poem is supportive of Matthew Arnold’s idea because it illustrates not only seclusion, but also delusion. The phrase “silent and mad” relates entirely back to Arnold’s “longing like despair”, which is the idea of being surrounded by nothingness causing mental madness and insanity. Both artists are acutely aware of the suffering brought on by their

Get Access