STUDENT: NICCI SWAN
3.1: HIGH RENAISSANCE VS. MANNERIST COMPARISON
INSTRUCTOR: STEPHEN WILLIAMS
DATE DUE: 9/24/17
Page 1
The Late Renaissance period was influenced by Ancient Greek and Roman classical cultures and philosophies of art style. This period was based on humanism and Neoplatonism style. Leonardo, Michelangelo, and Raphael were considered the Master Artists of the High Renaissance period and there individual art styles included: monumentality, balance, Sfumato, 3-D pyramid, using a primary color palette in one point perspective. ‘The Creation of Adam’ by Michelangelo between1508-1512 is located on the ceiling of The Sistine Chapel in Vatican City, Rome.
Michelangelo was a Neoplatonic thinker who believed that the image, figure or
…show more content…
The Florentine Mannerists were influenced by Late Renaissance Master artists of Raphael, Leonardo, and Michelangelo who brought harmonious styles forward into the Mannerism period.
The “Sack of Rome" was the defining historical event of the Mannerist period. The Mannerists did not learn and create from nature, live models, or mathematical theory. The Master artists of the Mannerism period chose to develop their own style and skills further by creating a stylistic art period between 1520 and 1600.
Pontormo was a reclusive artist, and many of his works have an otherworldly quality heightens their spiritual intensity. This quality is seen in his Deposition (1525-1528, Church of Santa Felicitá, Florence), an altarpiece painted with luminous tints of pink, orange, blue-violet, and green. The lack of dark shadows in this painting, as well as the sense that the figures are weightlessly suspended in space, adds to the work’s strange beauty. The painting shows the body of Christ being taken from his mother Mary’s arms after the crucifixion; a figure standing to the right of the blue-robed Mary is Pontormo
…show more content…
STUDENT: NICCI SWAN
3.1: HIGH RENAISSANCE VS. MANNERIST COMPARISON
INSTRUCTOR: STEPHEN WILLIAMS
DATE DUE: 9/24/17
Page 4
Pontormo focused on adding distorted figures that defined natural body curves and movements. The composition of ‘Descent from the Cross’ is too crowded, the forms are compressed into the foreground, and has a central void. His color choices were known as a ‘sour palette’, during the Mannerism art period. He experimented freely with traditional subjects from the Bible and mythical religious themes by incorporating dark visual references. The painting hangs in a dark corner of Florence's Capponi Chapel half-human, half-reptile subjects, adding drama to the composition.
STUDENT: NICCI SWAN
3.1: HIGH RENAISSANCE VS. MANNERIST COMPARISON
INSTRUCTOR: STEPHEN WILLIAMS
DATE DUE: 9/24/17
Page 5
Pontormo was amused at painting human figures using ‘contorted or twisted’ poses. Creating an ’illusion of art forms’ projecting into space, and stretched beyond what was considered natural and realistic. The goals of the earlier Mannerist art movement was to create similar proportions of the human body from the High Renaissance period, but enhance human form into conforming
Giotto di Bondonne created “Lamentation” circa 1305. This piece depicts Jesus Christ removed from the cross as Mary the Virgin embraces Him. There are two figures in the foreground with their backs facing the audience. Dawning a new style of artwork creating a sense of depth. John the Baptist is seen flailing his arms backwards. Body gestures were stiff and stern in comparison to previous works. Bondonne is an early artist in “the revival of the visual arts” by painting a scene to suggest a story (Richards). For example, angels are captured flying in the distance watching the people care for the deceased Jesus Christ. They grieve in unison with the crowd down below. Bondonne successfully creates a feeling of three dimensions by including a cluster of people on the far left tucked away in the corner. The mass of people gathered around to offer praise for His ultimate sacrifice.
The Renaissance began in the 1300’s and brought with it many new ideas and ways of thinking. The main one of these ideas being humanism, or that the best that a man can be is greater than the idea of theology. The Italians began to spread this idea and it began to grow. The Italians decided that the best way to express and spread the idea of humanism during the Renaissance was through their sculptures and paintings. This can be seen in many works of art from this time period such as the Mona Lisa by Leonardo da Vinci, The School of Athens by Raphael, and Michelangelo's David.
Michelangelo’s art, which relied heavily on the human body reflected the Renaissance Period’s interest in humanism and the individual experience. Michelangelo often studied the human anatomy, and even looked at and dissected corpses. Great examples of this are two of his earlier sculptures; the Pietå and the David, revealed his true talent and also his disposition to bend rules of anatomy and proportion i the service of greater expressive power. His ability to portray humans in the Renaissance Period, which was his great talent, showing the values of the period though his sculptures and paintings, which appealed to the people of this period. Arguably his most well known work, the painting on the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel, which was painted to show humanity’s need for salvation offered by God through Jesus.
The ominous figure in the centre of the foreground - Jesus Christ hanging lifeless on the cross, in Luca di Tommè’s ‘The Crucifixion’, primarily catches the eye. The symmetrical arrangement of lamenting figures around the cross, as well as the gilded background, highlight him as the focal point of this artwork.
From the late fifteenth century to the genesis of the sixteenth, a new movement influenced art in Europe, expanding the bleak limits of past art and created some of the most memorable masterpieces in history. The creators of these artworks during these decades of the Renaissance include Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo Buonarroti, and Raphael Sanzio. Influenced and sometimes driven competitively by each other, these artists share differences and similarities in their life, art style and techniques, and interests.
In addition to, Italian Mannerism is a style of later Renaissance art, in which depicts a “self- conscious stylization involving caprice, complexity fantasy and polish (Kleiner ) .” Mannerism is the reaction to the features of the High Renaissance style. This style, can be seen as a rejection of classical themes of harmony and balance that are represented by Renaissance art pieces. Paintings in the mannerist style can be seen as an “exaggeration” or a parody of previous works, such as the Pieta executed by Michelangelo. Similar to other styles, Mannerism includes characteristics which make the style intricate. These characteristics include
In this painting, he is being accused by the woman to the soldier. Caravaggio portrays the story of the Denial of St. Peter, as told in all four Gospels (Matthew, John, Luke, Mark) of the Bible. When Jesus was arrested, he prophesied that Peter, his disciple would denounce his name
The Deposition from the Cross (Entombment of Christ) by Jacopo Pontormo was completed in 1528 and originally resided in the Florence Charterhouse as the main altarpiece. With it’s distinct iconography, the work was intended to show the public the raw suffering of Christ after his sacrifice and how those around him felt at the time of his death. It holds an uplifting and even hopeful tone with it’s “sour” color palette, a stable for the Mannerist movement.
Throughout time, many men and women have made legendary contributions for mankind today. Two of those people are Leonardo da Vinci and Michelangelo. Da Vinci and Michelangelo given society many new styles of education. They both specialized in science, mathematics, and modern art. They each lived completely different lifestyles yet they have impacted many others.
"The Renaissance was a rebirth that led to new ways of thinking in the sciences, philosophy, and architecture, as well as painting and sculpture" (Spence 6). This period of European history, beginning in the fourteenth-century, saw a renewed interest in the arts. It has been characterized by
From Pollaiuolo creator of the engraving Battle of the Nudes to Michelangelo's David the human form was not about reality but idealism the ultimate portrayal of God's ultimate creation. This perfected view of the human form can also be seen later in Da Vinci's Vitruvian Man and Michelangelo's muscular figures whether male or female. Humanism’s affects did not stop there. The topics of paintings also began to change. Botticelli’s Primavera and The Birth of Venus depict this change clearly. Both show mythological themes. The focus on these themes inspired Raphael and Titan to develop their famous pieces as the early Renaissance became the High Renaissance. From here interesting occurrences began to evolve. Humanism itself develops a new school of thought known as Neo-Platonism; an idea that mixes ancient philosophy and Christian truth. For example, the reaction to Botticelli's creations was that of others trying to find a religious meaning within the mythological topic. Slowly however, even this will fade as the Mannerist style develops. Along with the movement toward secular and eventually erotic portrayals of art the artist began to enjoy a new status. Duke explains that they became “practitioners of the high-status liberal arts” someone to be sought after, someone to study and someone to stand in awe of. Humanism’s affect spread north but there
Every painting is a unique experience for each individual person, therefore two of the artists that offered some of the most unique experiences where Leonardo da vinci and Michelangelo. While both of these painters are today well regarded and remembered, during their time they both had achieved such status in vastly different ways. Therefore even though these two artists lived during the same time these two are nothing alike. With their unique take on the world and events around them they were able to shape how the average person thought about the world around them.
Vittore Carpaccio’s symmetrical input truly served it’s purpose. Focusing on the center third of the painting, there’s a mere perfect symmetrical contrast of life and death top to bottom. Most impacting is the symmetrical division of the malnourished and tortured body of Jesus Christ, The left side of his body is in a lively sitting posture on the throne. While his right side is the embodiment of death, his punctured ribs and dangling arm. From the ground up, Carpaccio illustrates the contrast of life and death with minimal details in the painting. The supporting stones of the throne, directly below the arm rests, are divided by breakage, the left stone is cracked and falling apart, while the opposing stone appears to be intact. Vittore Carpaccio managed to capture the cycle of life with many elements one wouldn’t think of comparing life and death with. The top left portion of the throne is a half broken, followed by Jesus’s deadly posture to the falling apart ground stone of the throne, Death is captured in a very recognizable minimalistic form.
The works of Leonardo Da Vinci and Michelangelo influenced the art of the 16th century in Italy and Europe in many ways. Three of Michelangelo’s works such as: The Last Judgment, Pieta, and David were great works during his time. Leonardo da Vinci also contributed great works to the 15st century such as: The Last Supper, St. James in the Wilderness, and The Mona Lisa. Although there were some similarities in Leonardo da Vinci and Michelangelo’s works, their differences and uniqueness is what made their works great masterpieces of the 15th and 16th century.
Art during the Italian Renaissance differed from art during the Middle Ages. The two have contrasting characteristics and concepts. To the people in the medieval world, religion was their life. Everything in daily life focused around the church and God (Modern World 164). Medieval culture influenced the arts; this was evident in the religious themes. During the Italian Renaissance, painters and other artists focused on the portrayal of a more humanistic way of life. Renaissance artists’ work portrayed realism with “lifelike human figures in their paintings” (Modern World 164). Renaissance artists wanted to express ancient Greek and Roman cultures in their work (Modern World 162). Italian Renaissance