preview

Comparing Ahab And Ishmael's Visions Of Moby Dick

Decent Essays

In order to compare and contrast Ahab and Ishmael’s visions of the eponymous Moby Dick – and the quest to kill him – it is necessary to understand each man’s vision of the quest. Captain Ahab’s understanding of Moby Dick is multifaceted, including conceptions both personal and wide-thinking, both emotional and intellectual. It is appropriate, therefore, to examine this conception from the two sources Melville provides the reader: that from Ishmael, and that from Ahab’s own lips. From Ahab’s own lips, the reader learns “‘that my vengeance will fetch a great premium here’” at which point Ahab “‘smites his chest’” to drive the idea home – and foreshadow the self-destructive nature (“smite”) of the quest, which not coincidentally rhymes with “chest”– to his crew (Melville 139). Ahab’s quest, to his mind, will furnish him with desperately needed emotional and spiritual closure. But Ahab’s motivation for the quest is also very much intellectual, and he wants Starbuck – and the reader – to know this. He invites Starbuck to follow his thinking “the little lower layer” (Melville 140). Those “l” sounds in succession are difficult, when read aloud, to articulate without stammering; they force the mouth to slow down and be careful. Ahab wants his observers to slow down and carefully consider what he is about to say; he may be misanthropic, but he should not be misunderstood. Ahab muses, in a philosophy reminiscent of Plato’s ideals, that “‘all visible objects…are but as pasteboard

Get Access