Essay on Comparing Pygmalion and My Fair Lady

1009 Words 5 Pages
Comparing Pygmalion and My Fair Lady

Through the years, countless film directors have adapted and recreated various novels and plays to make them ideal for the big-screen. In many cases, directors strive to keep their screenplay adaptations true to the original literature; however, viewers often find contrasts in certain areas of the film. George Bernard Shaw, author of the play Pygmalion, who had passed away prior to the production of My Fair Lady in 1964, therefore, he could not assist in the transition from play to musical. For this reason, director George Cukor has attempted to retain some similarities and also incorporate a few changes of his own. Although readers can discover numerous similarities between My Fair Lady and
…show more content…
To begin with, Shaw and Cukor introduce the importance of social status in the opening scenes of their works. When Henry Higgins analyzes Eliza Doolittle in the film, he keeps a dry, condescending tone to make it clear that she should look up to him. On the other hand, in the play, Higgins speaks unsympathetic, degrading words and vilifies Liza?s whole existence. Unquestionably, during this time period, it is rather unlikely for aristocratic society to associate with the low-class citizens. The critic, Roger Ebert, states the modifications of the play and then the movie in the Ebert articles: ?The story?began as a Greek legend and was retold in Elizabethan and Victorian times and reached its present form as George Bernard Shaw?s ?Pygmalion? (1912), with its clear-eyed dissection of the British class system? (Ebert 1). Therefore, Cukor preserved a great deal of Shaw?s characterizations and utilized them for My Fair Lady.

Along with the aforementioned similarities in Pygmalion and My Fair Lady, one can also stumble upon a number of contradictions, including conclusions. Shaw had originally written his play without music, but Cukor later incorporates a score with the text. Critic Liz Burroughs believes that these changes are for the better. ?The additions of the Lerner & Loewe songs provide an extra dimension to the story, even if you
Open Document