Comparion of In Seach of Respect by Philippe Bourgous and Shattering Silence by Begona Aretxaga

1446 Words 6 Pages
In search of Respect by Philippe Bourgois and Shatteing Silence by Begona Aretxaga, are extremely great books which focus around similar themes. In this review both books will be separately analyzed and compared with one another. The content of shattering silence is pretty straight forward. The book contains issues on equality between genders and ethnicities as well. Shattering silence takes place in Ireland. Both In search of respect and shattering silence are set up with similar themes yet have different backgrounds, people and races. Begoña Aretxaga reviews the problems and promise of feminist change in Northern Ireland with the start of the “Troubles” in the start of the 1969 civil rights movement. She views the kinship of power and …show more content…
In search of Respect by Philippe Bourgois and Shatteing Silence by Begona Aretxaga, are extremely great books which focus around similar themes. In this review both books will be separately analyzed and compared with one another. The content of shattering silence is pretty straight forward. The book contains issues on equality between genders and ethnicities as well. Shattering silence takes place in Ireland. Both In search of respect and shattering silence are set up with similar themes yet have different backgrounds, people and races. Begoña Aretxaga reviews the problems and promise of feminist change in Northern Ireland with the start of the “Troubles” in the start of the 1969 civil rights movement. She views the kinship of power and politics through the entanglement of gender, class, republican nationalism, and colonialism. The place of working-class women in the Irish republican conflict has been both suppressed and misrecognized, not only in terms of their genuine participation, but also in terms of how their experience set-up the politics of the struggle both directly and indirectly. The political subjectivity of these working-class nationalist women was provoked, composed, rounded, and changed through the male-dominated struggle they helped define. Other than this, the book also explores “the effects that such subjectivity can produce on a political culture and on a gendered universe” (9). Ethnography of the violence in Northern Ireland, is a breakdown of a

More about Comparion of In Seach of Respect by Philippe Bourgous and Shattering Silence by Begona Aretxaga