preview

Contrasting Interactions with the Environment Depicted in Alice Munro's The Shining Houses

Decent Essays

How is our character revealed through our interaction with the natural world around us? Do we adapt to fit in with nature, or do we force the landscape to conform to our ideals of lifestyle? In the short story “The Shining Houses”, Alice Munro addresses the contrast in lifestyle ideologies between two generations through their interactions with the natural environment they populate. The older generation is content to live in harmony with the existing natural world and develop its infrastructure amongst the present landscape. Meanwhile, the younger generation believes in destroying the original terrain by constructing a new environment fitted to a theme of exoticism and novelty. The observation of such interaction with the environment …show more content…

Construction of the city consumes minimal resources because the assets already present are conserved rather than destroyed. The houses themselves, although “unpainted and patched” are simple but effective structures. This shows how rather than dwelling on superfluous aesthetics, the older generation devotes itself to more fruitful endeavors. For example, residences sport compost heaps. The implementation of such devices preserves and recycles many resources, further emphasizing the conservative ideology of the older generation. While their practical lifestyle is compared to “savagery” by the younger generation, the city of the old generation is really an example of their efficiency.

On the contrary, the lifestyle of the younger generation is one that embraces radical alteration of the surrounding environment to match a visual image created by the movers-in. Young men, unfamiliar with manual labor, work hard to cut and burn the bushes which surround their homes, in the hopes that in two years their yards may be decorated by “ornamental shrubs”. Either they have very specific tastes in exotic shrubbery or they have despicable planning skills. The fact that the men are young professionals would suggest the former. Even so, they persist at their contradictory task during the weekend. The fact that such weekends could be spent with family would suggest that the priority the men

Get Access