Research Question
According to “Moving Beyond the Pain: Women’s Responses to the Perinatal Period After Childhood Sexual Abuse,” 1 in 9 pregnant women have experienced some type of childhood sexual abuse also known as CSA (Roller, 2011). The purpose of this study was to develop a hypothetical outline for practitioners to better understand how CSA women cope with the possible pain of reliving their CSA trauma during the perinatal period.
Research Design
The study is a qualitative study, which explores subjective and descriptive information from its participants to gather information such as opinions, ideas, and behaviors. The information that is gathered can help provide an understanding of a problem or provide possible resolutions to problems
…show more content…
This technique was one of the strengths of the study, providing a more focused response from the participants in regards to their experiences with CSA and the effects it had on their pregnancy. Secondly, the study did not focus on interventions and rather concentrated on gathering insights from participants with real-life experiences of CSA and how they survive through pregnancies, which has the potential to cause flashbacks of their past trauma. In order to provide holistic care, providers must first understand why and how their patients react to certain situations. Another strength of the study was that it yielded similar findings of other research studies, which supported the researcher’s findings of how women survive flashbacks of CSA throughout the perinatal period (Roller, …show more content…
The first limitation was that most of the participants were of African-American descent and therefore did not show the diversity within the study. Providing diversity within the study may have given insight into cultural differences of coping mechanisms and a better understanding of how providers can provide more culturally appropriate interventions. Another limitation that the researcher mentioned was that the information gathered in regards to the participant’s CSA came from their memory and therefore could have been altered over time. The researcher also stated that the participants were not properly screened for PTSD and consequently it was unknown whether they had already recovered from it. This could potentially alter the way participants handle their triggers, which would ultimately change the results and validity of the study (Roller, 2011).
Future Research The researcher suggested that further exploration into PTSD could help to further develop the framework of the three phases (Roller, 2011).
Clinical Significance and
Historically perinatal loss such as stillborn is rarely a topic of discussion. (Avelin, Erlandsson, Hildingsson, & Rådestad, 2011). Stillborn loss was not viewed as an problem, and was expected for mothers to forget about the baby, and have another one, while siblings were told to forget about the baby and not talk about the loss (Avelin et al., 2011). Perinatal loss responses can be vary widely as it covers variety of loss from pregnancy to birth within a few weeks, but most often it is an unexpected loss for many families who typically do not know what to do, what to expect and how to handle grief (O’leary & Warland, 2013). Furthermore, there is very little information on Stillbirth experiences especially about men who lose their child(Bonnette & Broom, 2012). Experiencing the loss of a child can be very difficult and often complicate grief which can affect parents social well being (Kersting & Wagner, 2012). In pregnancies that follows a loss such as perinatal loss, it has been found that parents experience high levels of psychological distress, anxiety, depression and post-traumatic stress. (O’leary & Warland, 2013; Kersting & Wagner, 2012)
The phenomenon of interest (birth trauma and what it means to women) was clearly identified in the report. In the introduction the authors stated that women’s perception of birth trauma is quite different from the perception of the same phenomenon by health care providers. She also uses a term “in the eyes of the beholder” to emphasize that for every woman this phenomenon is unique. It is stated that PTSD after childbirth is quite prevalent and several studies support this fact. However, research is regarding the understanding of the birth trauma phenomenon from the woman’s experience lacking. The problem statement was worded clearly and directly and I wasn’t ambivalent about what problem will be discussed in the remainder of the article.
Seven Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and quasi-randomised trials from OK, Australia and Sweden comparing postnatal debriefing interventions with standard postnatal care were included. The intervention consisted of at least one debriefing intervention session, which had the purpose of allowing women to describe their experience and to normalise their emotional reaction to that experience. No difference between standard postnatal care with debriefing and otherwise was noted within three months postpartum or at three to six months postpartum. The authors concluded that there is no evidence to support either any effect of psychological debriefing for the prevention of psychological trauma in women following childbirth. (Bastos, Furuta,
Domestic violence is a topic that is under discussed and people need to be more educated on it. The impact of abuse cannot only harm the victim, but can also impact the lives of those in the victim’s life. During our class discussion, Christae stated, “ Most abuse occurs for the first time while a woman is pregnant”. This statement made me question how being abused while pregnant could ultimately affect the victim. I came across a study conducted by Chan et al. (2012) that analyzed the idea that violence against a pregnant woman cannot only affect herself, but also the child that she is carrying. This study had two main objectives which were to assess the impact of intimate partner violence (IPV) against pregnant women who have exhibited child abuse and neglect (CAN), as well as addressing the link between mediation and intervention of IPV and subsequent CAN.
In different studies such as Elsevier Editorial System (tm) for Midwifery Manuscript Draft by Rhonda Joy Boorman has shown that recent research in Australia found that 45.5% of women birthing are seemingly to report childbearing as traumatic (Alcorn et al., 2010), resulting in a projected 135,000 Australian women annually self-rating parturition as traumatic. Experiencing a traumatic birth could negatively impact on a woman's emotional
Women often feel unprepared for the degree of perineal pain that they experience postnatally and its impact on activities of daily living, reporting feelings of isolation and lack of support throughout the postnatal period (Herron-Marx, Williams and Hicks, 2007a), therefore, encompassing community and hospital based midwifery care. Enduring perineal pain has long-term implications including depression (Pairman et al., 2011), with evidence supporting that the delivery of postnatal care is too short, as some women experience pain up until three months postnatally suffering in silence as there is no appropriate professional input (Whapples, 2014).
The trauma that comes along with abortion is not as lasting as one might think, it is researched
Those women also suffer from anxiety, anger, guilt, grief and panic (Beck, 2006; Allen, 1998). This experience left women to struggle with nightmares and flashback even years after birth due to dysfunctional coping strategies (Elmir et al., 2010; Simpson &Catling, 2015; Fenech &Thomson, 2014). Traumatic childbirth leads women to experience feeling of loss; loss of self, motherhood, and loss of family values. Traumatic childbirth disturbed the women’s relationships with her partner and her child, such as loss of sexual desire and intimacy, and impaired mother –infant attachment (Elmir et al., 2010; Fenech &Thomson, 2014). Subsequent pregnancies were affected by the experience of traumatic childbirth as those women developed secondary tocophopia or fear of childbirth, which was associated with women decision not to have any subsequent pregnancy or request caesarean section for subsequent births (Elmir et al.,
In conclusion, trauma does not limited itself to a society class, ethnicity group nor is it limited to a particular act; instead, trauma is an experience that extends itself in the moments when the human body’s natural response to discomfort and or fear fails to save and protect. Experiencing sexual abuse during childhood development is defined as a crisis. During that stage of human development, a child is not equipped with the proper tools to combat the physical, emotional, or spiritual ramifications of the act, and their natural ability for fight or flight does not impede the reoccurrence of the event. The child then develops into an adult with maladaptive coping skills to respond to external pain and disappointments. In some, an anxiety
The type of study that was utilized is known as a qualitative study. A qualitative study is a study in which data is gathered without altering the surroundings. Within the area of human research, a qualitative study can present evidence about the health conditions, actions, and viewpoints that occur naturally in a particular group (research design, n.d). When researchers are required to interact with participants, surveys or interviews may be utilized to gather required data. In descriptive studies where the researcher does not communicate with the participant, observational studies of individuals in an environment, and studies containing data collection using current records are utilized (research design, n.d).
A study found women who had an abortion had significantly higher levels of anxiety and depression up to 5 years after the abortion. They also learned that the women are 3 times more likely to commit suicide than the average person and 6 times more than those who have the baby (“Should Abortion Be Legal?”) Abortion leaves many women emotionally scarred (Kumar 194-197). Abortions affect not only the mothers but the fathers as well. As much as 51.6% of fathers have had regrets after the abortion, 45.2% felt sad, and 25.8% experienced depression. Having an abortion can have a negative impact mentally and physically on a woman's life after the abortion (“Should Abortion Be
The qualitative research serves to comprehend and explain on what a participant means (Morrow, 2005). In a more elaborate manner, Creswell (1998) defines qualitative research to be an analytical
Qualitative research involves the process of discovering not only what people think but also why they believe it. The object is to get people to discuss their stance, beliefs, or viewpoints to acquire an understanding of their feelings and motivation. The qualitative research utilizes in-depth small group studies to steer and assists the development of theory. The outcome of qualitative research tends to be indicative of the opinion of the researcher rather than estimated.
More than fifty percent of women have regret after abortion. The majority of women who have abortions are depressed for years and years after the abortion. Studies show woman who have abortions are six to seven times more likely to commit suicide (Terzo). On many separate occasions women have reported having dreams about the child they aborted over and over and over again. Doctors at abortion clinics are misleading young scared pregnant woman and convincing them to have abortions. Some women are not warned about the emotional trauma that is in store from hem shortly following the termination of their child. Many women have shared that the doctors who performed their abortion ensured them this child was just a blob of tissue and it was no big deal that they were paying someone to murder their unborn
As women appropriate memories of CSA through the lens of the adult mind, the naturally ensuing questions of worth, identity and forgiveness will potentially challenge a system of belief in God. In attempting to bring this kaleidoscope of memories and life experiences into focus and for the victim to become a survivor, mentors, a community structure and a strong sense of conviction will aid in the development of resiliency. Within the spiritual model beliefs, values, social support, a sense of efficacy and hope are important; however, beliefs alone are inadequate for healing. Practical application of attitudes and beliefs is critical in providing a sense of relief and hope (Yarhouse et al., 2005, p. 43).