Drug Testing In Schools

Good Essays
Drug Testing in Schools Drug testing in schools is a very controversial issue with strong opponents and proponents. The controversy comes down to legality, safety, and privacy, with both sides of the argument having different perspectives on each. Drug testing for schools is a fairly recent development in the educational system, supposedly aimed at fighting an evolving drug problem in the United States. One side of the argument concludes that random drug testing is harmful, infringes on students’ rights, and is ineffective at solving the drug problem. “The first large-scale national study on student drug testing found no difference in schools that have drug testing programs and those that do not” (Appel). Side A claims that drug testing…show more content…
Side B believes that drug testing is not only effective, but it is legal and necessary. The point is made that random student drug testing programs (RSDT) have no negative impact on classroom, as observed by principals of schools that implemented an RSDT program (McKinney). In fact, “High schools with RSDT programs exceeded the state average for test scores on the state-mandated graduation test as well as exceeding the state average for graduation rates” (McKinney). Side B also states that RSDT is legal, as ruled by several state and federal courts, and that it is one of the few effective, legal ways to remove drugs from schools. According to a study, RSDT does not affect participation either as “0% of the high schools surveyed reported a reduction in student participation in athletic or extracurricular activities” and “46% of high schools reported increases in student participation in athletic activities” (McKinney). Side B takes a firm stand that drug testing is legal, effective, and does not harm to extracurriculars or…show more content…
This has been a topic that has only been recently discussed, with many concerns being raised about the application of these programs, or not having them at all. Overall, the main goal of this proposal is to come up with a plan that both satisfies the need for a drug testing program, and alleviates the concerns of those who are wary of drug testing for the reasons of legality and effectiveness. In order to solve the drug problem, there must be compromise in order to further our understanding of the issue at hand, and this proposed solution allows for compromise that all can agree on. Works Cited Appel, Judith, et al. "Random Drug Testing Is Harmful and Infringes on Students' Rights." Making Sense of Student Drug Testing: Why Educators Are Saying No. 2004. Rpt. in Students' Rights. Ed. Jamuna Carroll. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 2005. Opposing Viewpoints. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 23 Feb. 2017 McKinney, Joseph R. "Random Drug Testing Can Prevent Student Drug Abuse." Addiction. Ed. Christina Fisanick. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2009. Opposing Viewpoints. Rpt. from "The Effectiveness and Legality of Random Student Drug Testing Programs Revisited." 13 Dec. 2005. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 23 Feb.
Get Access