preview

Gay Rights Flawed

Good Essays

Is America’s Views on Gay Rights Flawed?
The struggle for gay rights is an ongoing political debate and has often been described as the next big step forward in human rights. In many countries gay rights groups openly protest primarily for the right to marry as heterosexual couples do. Do you believe that in America people persecute homosexuals?
The question often arises “Why do gay couples want to get married? Aren’t there other forms of union the state offers?” There are other alternatives to marriage that give gay couples the same tax benefits as other couples but, marriage allows for some benefits under taxes, medicare, and medical decisions that other types of union won’t allow.
One common problem that gay and lesbian couples face because …show more content…

The argument is much deeper then weather or not they should be married because they share a home together. If couples are paying taxes to build roads and help public schools, they should be afforded the same rights the heterosexual couples have. This was the argument used in the Baker v. Vermont. In the Baker v. Vermont court case, “gay and lesbian couples had argued that they were denied the protection of more than 300 laws as a result of not being allowed to marry.” Homosexuals are finally suing the state because they are not receiving protection under the laws of state strictly because they are gay. The Vermont House of Representatives voted in favor of a same-sex civil union bill after the case resolved. This shows that looking at the matter as a legal issue, it is evident that gay couples are not regarded equally in the eyes of the law, and that the first steps to fix this social injustice are just now being taken, however, the vote is very close. Same-sex civil unions are a basis for nation-wide legal recognition of same-sex relationships. These same-sex civil marriages are demonstrating that the principals of “marriage” and the rights an American deserves, regardless of gender, race or sexual orientation, can be respected. …show more content…

The battle to legalize same-sex civil unions is not trying to change the beliefs of the churches. These unions are to be recognized by the state. Priests are not forced to perform these ceremonies, nor do they have to be held in a church. It would be unfair for the government to decide what people should and should not believe, this would impair our right to freedom of religion. But, this does not give the government the right to discriminate against gay and lesbian couples in the eyes of the law, because the government and religious beliefs are separate. If same-sex civil unions should be recognized legally is not a religious question. This is a debate over whether or not people of different sexual orientation are to be viewed equally in the eyes of the

Get Access