The Comparison of Gone Girl and Macbeth Gone Girl is a bestseller and loved by millions, it compliments english literature and course themes. Grade 11 courses would benefit from replacing boring, old Macbeth with the thriller, Gone Girl. Not only is Gone Girl an overall better, more intriguing book, it also has more of an educational value when compared with Macbeth. It has many ties into the established curriculum and creates better learning opportunities. Both students and the school system would greatly benefit from swapping Shakespeare's Macbeth with Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl. The Storyline of Gone Girl makes for such an interesting read, far more intriguing than Macbeth. Without incorporating the educational ways Gone Girl is a superior …show more content…
From a learning standpoint Flynn uses more literary and rhetorical devices in the text. Students find this book easier to analyse and have more understanding of the devices being used because of how prominent they are, while in Macbeth it is extremely difficult to identify the use of any elements. For example Gone Girl is written using many examples of symbolism, set into the story to give Nick and Amy’s struggle more emotion. For example In the Punch and Judy story, Punch kills his child, then murders Judy when she discovers what he’s done. He then goes on to encounter a police officer, a doctor, a hangman, and even the devil, and beats all of them to death with a club. The person getting away with murder in Gone Girl, though, is Amy as Judy, instead of Punch. Besides the obvious similarities with the story she makes up, Amy has other reasons for choosing Punch and Judy as a symbol. The puppets are also a metaphor for Amy's manipulative tactics and her attempts to control people. In Macbeth there is some symbolism. The hallucinations Lady Macbeth's endures symbolize guilt. These symbols are hard to pick out of the text, and do not allow students to analyze the literary elements of the play. There are other symbols such as the weather, for example when it is very stormy while the murder of King Duncan is committed, this is a more obvious example and does not require students to think and decipher the text. The way of …show more content…
It compliments english literature and course themes. Not only is Gone Girl a more immersive and complex read, it’s educational value compared to the established curriculum is more compatible than Macbeth. Overall the book creates better learning opportunities for students while the readers get to read an amazing novel. Grade 11 courses everywhere would greatly benefit from replacing the outdated Macbeth with the psycho thriller, Gone
Although an astonishing film, it is not without flaws. I believe that the three witches played to much of a foreshadowing role, too much of the storyline is given away, especially when the witches encounter Macbeth. To me it takes away the suspense of huge events that have yet to occur. An example would be when Macbeth approaches the witches in their home and they say to him “Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Beware of Macduff! Beware the Thane of Fife.” (Act 4 scene 1). Revealing to him his biggest threat to the
The play Macbeth is a story in which many different themes are represented. A man named Macbeth becomes king of Scotland by murdering the former king, which leads to further violence, deceit, and corruption. It’s a story with different characters who personify power, deception, manipulation, and loyalty. Although it is certainly a very unique story, it also shares some similarities with the movie Mean Girls. Despite the different time periods, the plot and characters in Mean Girls truly reflect that of Macbeth. Between these two stories, there are several themes including deception, appearance vs. reality, and manipulation.
When Romeo and Juliet comes up in school curriculum any observer can see students eagerly signing up for roles, puzzling over Juliet’s eagerness to marry a stranger, or rehearsing their own unique interpretation of the play. In these moments students are released from the usual monotonous class period and allowed to enjoy a timeless piece of literature. While some may claim that Shakespeare is outdated or difficult to read, the positivities of including it in ninth grade curriculum far outweigh any struggles of comprehension.
”Macbeth retold” uses themes similar to the original play but uses a modified plot to appeal to the more modern audience. Retold utilises settings to create a controversial atmosphere. In contrast Shakespeare’s Macbeth uses an array of themes, a historical plot and language features that revolve around Elizabethan times. Even though the similarities are quite apparent, there are also some less obvious differences, the differences improve the sensitive response and the understanding that a modern audience may consume.
If one was able to look into our classroom, they would see the kids rushing to the whiteboard to try and get a part that they can read. Spots filled, they anxiously wait to continue on with the story. Then that person would ask, “Why would they be so excited to read something so old and outdated?” Well to answer, it’s because Shakespeare’s work is still applicable to our lives today. Shakespeare should stay in the 9th grade curriculum, because it strongly relates to today's day and age, keeps the kids in the class active and paying attention, and helps convey a strong message that everyone should follow.
1595? Has there really not been any better pieces of literature written in the last 422 years? Believe it or not, things have changed; electricity was invented, world war I and II have taken place as well as the revolution, and yet we still insist on teaching students literature that doesn’t apply to our world today at all. William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet should not be taught in high schools, because it uses language that is too complicated for students to understand, it takes far too long to teach, and students are taking nothing away from the reading.
Some people think that the play, Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare, should not be taught in school. Others think that it should. In my opinion, this great story should be taught in school. It has so much potential to teach students about great pieces of literature. A story about two lovers that cannot love – such an interesting classic to read. “..It is founded on an idle passion between a boy and a girl, who have scarcely seen and can have but little sympathy or rational esteem for one another, who have had no experience of the good or ills of life and whose raptures or despair must be therefore equally groundless and fantastical” (Hazlitt 33). It has a lot of vocab in it, which will help students enhance their vocab skills, it will stretch students’ reading areas because when people read it, they have a harder time than normal to read, and it will help people understand other hard pieces of writing later on in life. The great story by William Shakespeare, Romeo and Juliet, an overall great story, should be read in school because it
Romeo and Juliet should still be taught since it’s relevant because there still are rebellious teenagers. Juliet thinking that she
In Macbeth, the witches exemplify some of the important themes through their supernatural abilities, and these themes are important to deliver the
In both plays, there was different methods to create drama. In both movies I watched, the drama was completely different. In Macbeth, one way that drama was created was when Macbeth stabbed another man in his sleep and some of the girls saw Macbeth killing King Duncan so that he could take the Scottish throne. Most people were not that happy with what Macbeth did because his actions were wrong and it created a bunch of drama with the people. Lady Macbeth started to feel the guilt of all the crime that her and her husband comminuted. Macbeth was stabbing King Duncan, Lady Macbeth had to take over Macbeth because Macbeth would not stop stabbing the King. There were rumors that Macbeth was going to have a couple people kill Banquo. So Banquo was trying to talk to Macbeth, but Macbeth had hired three men to kill Banquo so they did just that.
To teach Macbeth, or not to teach Macbeth-- That is the question. Shakespeare has added over 1,700 words and phrases to English. With works translated into almost every language, Shakespeare has a heavy influence on today’s culture. But should we still be reading material that is over 400 years old? And which book from Shakespeare’s collection should be taught? Students should be exposed to Shakespeare’s Macbeth to refine analytical skills, to understand difficult concepts, and to assess current history.
The morals and values presented in his works speak to the audience, often offering a new perspective on the world in which they live. Students are affected by the powerful and complex characters and are rewarded with profound insights into human nature and behavior.I firmly believe that Shakespeare's works, like no other literature in the high school curriculum, challenge and invigorate the minds of students. Because of the complex characters, difficult vocabulary and style in which he writes, students must elevate their level of learning to grasp a clear understanding of his works. Shakespeare's plays hold intricate meanings and messages. His
The importance of continuing to read Macbeth in our modern society is to educate readers on valuable lessons in life. The significance of gaining power appropriately, the fact that there are consequences for every action and the importance of justice are a few of the many life lessons that are relevant in Shakespeare 's tragedy, Macbeth.
Macbeth is a complex and well developed character, while there are several interesting characters in the play, Macbeth is by far the most interesting. He is a tragic hero who experiences a slow and painful mental decline which is expressed in such a way that the audience is mesmerised.
As a virgin to The Shakespeare Theatre, I was pleasantly surprised when my recent encounter with Macbeth was a stimulating and enjoyable excursion. The two and a half hours I had predicted to be less than enchanting were filled with symbolism, and an overall attitude towards the Shakespeare classic that I had never contemplated before.