How Did Sparta Have The Geographic Advantage Above Athens

First reason, why Sparta would have been a better city is women were aloud to mary and be with anyone the wanted. Mr.Duckworth states in “Athens and Sparta” ,”women were stronger and they formed friendships with men as they chose.” So unlike Athens women were aloud to form friendships with men.

Sparta, a military city-state, and Athens, a very ethical city-state more concentrated on the arts and a better education, were two powerful city-states in Greece and were often at war with one another. Sparta and Athens were very different from the way they ruled, to the way they conducted their normal life. In my opinion, the better place to live depended on who you were. If you were a boy, Athens would be a more beneficial place to live as boys had many privileges during their childhood. Sparta would be the better place for a women to live because the rights they had, were more than an Athenian women had. If you were a man, the best place to live would be Athens, as he would have more freedoms and choices.

Athens had a geographic advantage because they were very superior. The Athens lived by the Sea which was an advantage because they had an excellent trading system. Even though the mountains protected Sparta it also caused trading problems, the Spartans had no way to get around the massive mountains to trade with people. Athens was located on the coast and included a harbor. The Athenians had an advantage and a disadvantage for them because they had easy water access but during the time of

From about the time of the Persian invasion until the Battle of Leuctra, Sparta was viewed as the powerhouse of the Greek city-states. There were numerous reasons behind their success, but there are few that stand out as the most prevalent. Spartan boys are born to be warriors, they are sent to the Agoge at the age of seven and forced to abide by the Laws set by Lycurgus the Lawgiver. Spartan men never had to worry about chores or any work that was done in the kleroi, allowing more time and focus to be dedicated towards militaristic training. The Spartan army had the ability to call upon the Perioikoi and Helots if need be as extra warriors, which became a significant advantage at time. These reasons, along with

Athens was superior to Sparta because of its beneficial economy, democratic government, and well-rounded education. Economy made Athens superior to Sparta because of its trade and currency. There was not enough land around Athens for all of the citizens to farm, so trade was essential for Athens. Athens was near the sea and had a good harbor, so trade flourished. Trade helped Athens obtain the supplies they did not already have, such as grain and wood (Frey 286).

Athens, the most famous and richest of the Greek city states dominated the ancient world for a long time. The Athenians developed, many new war tactics that were adopted by other Greek city states. Sparta was also a powerful Greek city state and one of the most feared military powers in the ancient world. Spartans grew up in a different society and used many war tactics that were different from traditional Greek warfare (Paton). At one point in time, Athens and Sparta were the most powerful civilizations in the whole world thanks to their very effective war tactics. Some strategies they used were good armor, intense training and surprise attacks. Spartans began training at a young age and were fierce fighters. Athens was rich and had a good navy. In the Persian war, Athens and Sparta worked together and ended up winning. But Athens and Sparta were two very different societies (Hayes 117). Even though the Spartans won the war the golden age of Greece ended this show how military power can make or destroy a great civilization.

Sparta is a better place to have an exciting or joyful life because you would be isolated by mountains and oceans. These mountains and oceans would make Sparta would be in a condition of prosperity and comfort. Sparta also has a great military strength, it is much better than Athens military because the men go to war at the age of 7-30. The Spartan men get more and children become great warriors because they at war and war training for 23 years. Spartan women are better than Athenian women because they have more rights, these rights coclude of being able to marry anyone they wish to. Spartan

The strengths in Sparta never even had a chance at outweighing the weaknesses for those reasons. To start off, Spartans were never taught formal education, Sparta focused on their military almost all the time, they were taught practical reading and writing, and were never allowed foreign teachers and were never allowed to travel to other places. It says in Document D that “all other forms of education were banned from the country”. They felt that if they allowed other people from other areas into their country,

n the beginning of this section, the Athenians are made to look better than the Spartans when they are ready and willing to fight the Persians again while the Spartans remained at home. The Athenians sent a messenger to the Spartans saying, “You agreed with us to oppose the invader in Boeotia, but you broke your word and allowed him to invade Attica…However, your immediate duty is to…put your army in the field,” and the Spartans reluctantly and after some time put their army in the field (556). Later, the Athenians military roles are highlighted when the Megarians were being pressed by the Persians and needed assistance, “nobody was willing to go except the Athenians” (562). When decided which troops would get to hold one of the wings, the

In the beginning, Sparta had a good foundation, with sufficient natural defenses (Freeman, 2004, pg. 168). Spartan culture emphasized courage and immortal honor imbued to forfeiting your life by dying in service to one’s home city, not to mention bringing glory to your family (Freeman, 2004, pg. 164). Shortly following Sparta’s inception began their excursions into conflagration, starting with those located closest to them, bringing them to dependence on Sparta and forcing them to contribute manpower to the Spartan army and yet not allowing them to participate in the governance of Sparta (Freeman, 2004, pg. 168). Despite no clear cause or need for further expansion (such as Athens dire need for grain) and an increasingly less defendable border, the Spartans became greedier still, seeking more land and dominance (Freeman, 2004, pg. 168-169).

The military might in athens is superior to sparta easily. Our cavalry the hippeus were trained to fight on horseback and easily overtake the heavier

First and foremost,Spartans had a better army. According to the text it says that the Athens were even scared of them. With a strong army, we could always be every war that comes to our path. Athenians knew if they would try to mess with them they will be put down also Spartans were great thinkers so they

Two Ancient Greek civilizations that are similar yet so different are the Athenians and the Spartans. Athens was the capital and largest city of Greece. In ancient times, its population was 140,000 people. This civilization was dependent on trade and agriculture. The Athenians invented democracy. Sparta was a warrior society in ancient Greece. Spartan culture was centered on loyalty to the state and military service. As this essay continues, you will see the similarities and differences between these two civilizations.

As the ancient Greek history shows, two well-known cities were Sparta and Athens. Each city-state was built on different and similar values. However if one was to compare these equally great city-states under the same umbrella, the question regarding which one had the best expression of arete would arise? In my critical opinion, Sparta was more representative of arete due to focusing completely on their primary goal: to be brave warriors.

The geography of Sparta provided a far greater advantage than that of Athens. Sparta had a tremendous water source as , “The