Men and woman live together side by side. We go to work, get married, have kids, amongst many other things. But are we dramatically different from each other? Some would say yes automatically based on things like, “he’s not sensitive enough” or “she talks to much”. But stereotypes aside, are we more similar? My theory is that yes we are more similar than different. The research out there even supports the idea.
From the American Psychological association, it tells us about Psychologist Janet Shibley Hyde, PhD, of the University of Wisconsin in Madison. Back in the 1980’s she reviewed prior research in regards to how gender affects us psychologically. The study showed differences had “no or a very small effect on most of the
…show more content…
Strength) there wasn’t much similarity. There was overlap on the psychological level. This coming from data from when people’s roles weren’t as fluid, said the researchers cited in an article by Live Science. Overall it leads myself, to the conclusion that what differences there are should not be taken heavy into consideration of what is a certain sexes’ characteristic and what limitations there are between the genders. This is even quoted so in this statement from the two.. Carothers and Ries say, “differences are not consistent or big enough to accurately diagnose group membership” and should not be misconstrued as evidence for consistent and inflexible gender categories,”
The final study on similarities versus difference came up with results similar to the prior research conducted thus far. But, it was made on a much grander scale than the previous ones. In an article from Iowa State University, it discusses a team of 3 researchers, Zlatan Krizan, an associate professor of psychology at ISU, Ethan Zell, an assistant professor at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro, and Sabrina Teeter, a graduate student at Western Carolina University. Together they conducted a mass meta synthesis of over 100 meta analyses which encompassed the data on more than 12 million people. In the conclusion of the report that was published in the American Psychologist, “found an almost 80 percent overlap for more than 75 percent of the psychological
Since the beginning of time there has been a distinct division between the sexes. Through sheer definition there is a physical difference between the two but as time has passed there has been an indisputable recognition of the differences in personality and cognition. There are also undeniable differences in the life experiences had by the two sexes that
The tests involved 23 women and two males for a period of 90 days and her results were a substantial influence of the psychology of women. She concluded that there were no significant differences in scores at any time during the 90 day period with women. Thus, disproving another commonly held position about women at the
In comparison to the module, the author Hyde and Else-Quest, state that women are more likely to be
For thousands of years, established gender roles have been a part of our society. Women are commonly known as sensitive, emotional, or passive. On the contrary, men are described as rational, competitive, independent, or aggressive. Believing women are more emotional than men is stereotyping. However, the stereotype is not entirely untrue. Development of gender roles is often conditioned more by environmental or cultural factors than by hereditary or biological factors. The development of gender roles between men and women involves the inference of peer community of each gender, the communication style of male and female and the intimacy or connection level of men and women.
Some of these gender roles and stereotypes have been created due to the differences in physique, thinking, personality, and behavior that is actually present between men and females. Physical differences are more visible to the eye due to the distinction between primary and secondary sex characteristics for each gender. Males have testes, deeper voices, a bigger body type, and more facial hair, where as women have a smaller body, higher voices, ovaries, and wider hips. (Rathus, 2010, p.448). Cognitive differences have to do with the brain and the way men and women
There has been research conducted between men and women, based on both of these traditions and the measurement of the traits or abilities. The reading also focuses on the gender bias that can occur when conducting the studies of measuring the differences between men and women. In the reading, it states that, “One of the most persistent sources of bias in gender-difference research is the difficulty of separating gender from all other factors...” (97). Furthermore, the reading explains that when conducting research on measuring gender differences there is a method called “meta-analysis”. This is a technique where researchers can look at the results of many studies that focuses on a specific topic. What I found interesting out of both readings is that in the first reading the author argues against the fact that clinicians and psychiatrists fail to see beyond norms that are held by the society and don’t consider looking at the social context of men and women. In the other reading I also found it interesting and questioned the reason why, professional journals are less likely to publish articles about the similarities found in men and women, but are more likely to publish articles of the differences found in men and women. Why is that
Gender roles govern the way that most of the world’s population interact with one another. Many African cultures uphold deeply patriarchal gender roles which dictate how women and men interact with one another. Chimimanda Ngozi Adichie, a staunch feminist, gives readers a look into Nigerian gender roles in her short story Birdsong. Her writing in Birdsong and her TEDtalks explore and expose how these gender roles are harmful and how important it is for many stories of young women of color to be heard.
Gender identity is the personal conception of being a man or a woman and the society creates standards and comes up with gender roles basing them on existing norms and traditions which will in turn influence gender identity. For instance, most societies associate strength and dominance to be masculine roles while caring and assisting or subordination known to be feminine roles. This clearly makes gender identity be bred within the society. One’s identity is important as it influences his or her life through events like life experiences, how one is being taken or treated, how to do one associate or socialize with others, the type of job one will have to do and also opportunities that may come up favoring a certain type of gender identity. One is also likely to face obstacles or discrimination due to his or her identity.
Psychologist, and researcher from the Kinsey Institute, June M. Reinisch believes that biology and culture shape gender differences. She believes that men and women aren't the same. Simply that "equality does not mean being the same, it means having equal opportunities" (Men, Women).
It feels as though most of the time when thinking about psychology and the great contributions that have been made to it, that most of them have been from men, but along the way there have been several influential women that have contributed to the field of psychology as well. Just like men, there were several women who were pioneers, theorists, and counselors; many of these women have contributed to the field of psychology in their own special between the years of 1850 and 1950. Of all these amazing women who are pioneers, theorists, and counselors, the one who stands out the most is Anna Freud. This paper will go on to explain Anna Freud’s
With relevant theory and research evidence, critically discuss the view that there are gender differences in personality
No one would argue the fact that men and women are physically different. The physical differences are rather obvious and most of these can be seen and measured easily. Men, who are essentially built for physical confrontation and the use of force, usually have greater upper body strength, build muscle easily, have thicker skin, and mostly use the left side of their brain. Women on the other hand, have a higher percentage of body fat, and a wider pelvis. Women also have four times as many brain cells connecting the right and left side of their brain. This provides physical evidence that supports the observation that men rely easily and more heavily on their left brain to solve one problem one step at
First of all, it is true that there are several things that uniquely distinguished males from females in terms of roles play within the society, the physical appearance, voice, brain cells, brain size, communication skills and career selections.
Within are experiment we will be assessing whether or not opposite sexes, can hold opposing personality traits, therefore a Jung(1968), supports this notion as he developed the idea of ‘archetypes’ when referencing to gender roles within the subconscious, he believed that within males there is a feminine part of their psych inherited by the mother. The Females have an Animus, this is a masculine part within their psyche inherited by their father. However, Jung could have been leading the audiences to the conclusion of these archetypes and no other expectation for different personalities, furthermore this is an old reference , which could potentially be out dated (Jung C 1968 Vol.9, Part1)
The men and women in the ‘masculine man/feminine woman’ dyads not only talked, looked, gestured, and smiled at each other significantly less than the men and women in the remaining dyad types, but expressed considerably less liking for each other as well” (Ickes & Barnes, p. 72, 1978).