preview

Klooster And O'shaughnessy

Decent Essays

The publications by Palmer, Greene, O’Shaughnessy, and Wooster have insightful differences involving the time period of the Stamp Act. By reviewing the author’s sources, methods, and areas of focus, a comparative lens can be used to elucidate the influences of mainland colonies and the development of opposing political ideologies throughout the British Empire. The two theories that are discussed throughout the publications are taxation without representation along with individuals sacrificing certain rights for the general well being of the entire British Empire. Klooster and O’Shaughnessy both discuss the concept of taxation without representation. Klooster focuses on mainland colonies with a detailed review of previous tax acts leading up to the Stamp Act. He brings into light the parliament’s position that the colonies were virtually represented in government through their business relationships and influences. O’Shaughnessy discussed the same concept throughout the British Caribbean and agrees with Klooster that all laws must be approved by local assembly. He additionally advances the discussion into a second philosophy. Although all islands opposed the Stamp Act, not all responses were the same. Leaders in Jamaica and Barbados opposed the tax peacefully with petitions and debate while St Kitts and Nevis erupted in violent opposition. The underlying theory among the peaceful protesters was that although they disagreed with the …show more content…

Green’s publication Colonial History and National History: Reflections on a Continuing Problem is a discussion on the categorization of colonial history. In his article he argues for colonial historians to take an imperial perspective and avoid lumping colonial history into national history. Although the other readings do not specifically discuss the academic breakdown of this era, Klooster does exhibit a historical separation when he divides description of North America into a colonial and a British Empire

Get Access