preview

Lúthien Foil

Decent Essays

Going along with an expanded life span, Galadriel also had to deal with grief for a long and probably distressingly painful amount of time. Throughout her prolonged life she dealt with whatever came her way in a stern yet passive way, rarely actually taking action from what Tolkien shows us. However, the movie adaptations do give her more of an active life. Lúthien in this regard is almost a foil to Galadriel because she was all about action. When her true love was being held captive by Sauron she sprang into action saving him from immeasurable pain and suffering. From there if Beren went somewhere she went too, never backing away from a fight. She truly was an elf maiden of action, even at one-point begging Mandos for the life of Beren, Lúthien cared more for personal relationships that gaining wisdom. It is uncertain whether Galadriel would have attempted these same actions or rather just accept her faith. Nether option is wrong or right, just different sides to the same coin. …show more content…

However, this does not stop the characters from having basic characteristics that follow them throughout the saga. This is the case of Arwen Evenstar. She is known as the living reincarnation of Lúthien, even admitting to Aragorn in the appendix A of The Return of the King saying, “‘So many have said,’ she answered gravely. ‘Yet her name is not mine. Though maybe my doom will be not unlike hers. . . (339).’” Her prediction came true in the book, perhaps she is like Lúthien in regards to appearances and eventual destiny, but in basic personality they were not as similar. Arwen was gentle and reserved, she positively was the ideal elf maiden, reflecting the beauty of the night and wielding wisdom as her primary weapon. And wise Arwen was, after spending many years under the tutelage of Galadriel she knew what was best, and not only for

Get Access