preview

Neither Wolf Nor Dog By Kent Nerburn

Good Essays

“”Here,” he said. “Give me your hand. We are brothers. You are my son. I pass to you my vision, even though I cannot pass to you my knowledge. There lies in the ground not far from here one who truly was my son. He could not bear the pain of knowing two truths. And so I give my vision to you who knows one one. Perhaps it will be easier to bear. Perhaps it will be easier to share.”” Throughout the book Neither Wolf Nor Dog by Kent Nerburn, the author travels a long way from his home to visit the reservation of a Native American elder named Dan. Nerburn agrees to write a book for Dan that will attempt to convey some aspects of American Indian life and truth in contrast to false images displayed in pop culture. This passage contributes to the …show more content…

“In a few sentences I had discovered more about Dan than I had learned in being around him for several months. It made me realize how closed-mouthed he had been”(237). Although Nerburn and Dan are complete strangers at first, Dan has an understanding of Nerburn because of his ability to observe him. While Nerburn doesn’t learn much about Dan unless it is said. Nerburn’s understanding of Dan doesn’t start forming until later in the book because of how he likes to keep the upper hand, but when Nerburn learned more about Dan from his granddaughter, he began to develop a whole new understanding of Dan. The passage relates to the character development of Dan and Nerburn because by the end of their journey, they have a new understanding of each other, and an everlasting bond. Once Nerburn learns to observe Dan, he begins to understand him deeper. For example, when Nerburn and Dan get into a heated discussion about Indian children, Nerburn is able to observe Dan. “This conversation was too loaded. I wanted out of it. But Dan was anxious for more. He was obviously pleased with my admissions”(260). Nerburn realizes that by observing like Dan, he can keep the upper hand like Dan does. Additionally, now that Nerburn and Dan are able to understand each other better, they develop a stronger connection and start thinking alike. For example, while Nerburn and Dan visiting wounded knee, Dan says “You have spoken well. Your words could have been my words. I, too am

Get Access