preview

Noir Film Analysis

Decent Essays

In Paul Schrader’s “notes on film noir” essay, he was carefully to describe a very vagueness to the almost genre of film noir. He made it clear that it is a genre that cannot be specifically pinned down to a single black and white definition. For example he very wisely described it by saying, “It is a film “noir”, as opposed to the possible variants of film gray or film off-white”. This explains how there is this subtle thing, or a je ne sais quoi, that belongs to film noir that makes it film noir. While this “thing” that belongs to film noir is a feeling, it is something that also is very specific to a era in time. Schrader says how it is “period of time in film history”, which goes to show how strange film noir is. How can something that is so nonspecific belong to something so specific at the same time? Charles Higham and Joel Greenberg’s essay “Noir Cinema” takes a liking to Schrader’s essay in the sense that it has the diversion to subject film noir to a hard definition. Though while Schrades like taking a stab at film noir through tones and influences, Higham and Greenberg seem to describe film noir in characters and images For example they say film noir lives in a world that is “always night, always foggy or wet, filled with gunshots and sobs, where men wear turned-down brims on their hats and women loom in fur coats, guns thrust deep into pockets”. These images that are described by Higham and Greenberg are the visual manifestation of Schrader’s je ne sais quoi of film noir. They are all of the different shades of black that make up film noir. Both of these descriptions of film noir take a compliment to each other, though they differ greatly in their categorization as Schrader says film noir is not quite a genre while Higham and Greenberg say it is. Higham and Greenberg like to focus on the effect of the female character, or femme fatale, of film noir. They seem to suggest that the tone of the film noir, which could be a good case, is dependent on the actions and character of the femme fatale of the film. The world of the films seems a little less corrupt and negative in general, when the femme fatale or female’s plot ends on a happier note. In a way, there definition of the film noir’s world is

Get Access