preview

Pentagon's Conundrum

Good Essays

In recent years technology has begun to grow at an astounding rate. Within the article “The Pentagon’s ‘Terminator conundrum” one such advancement in technology is discussed, describing the utilization of autonomous weapons within the military and the possibility of utilizing them to supersede human soldiers. While such technology seems like it wouldn’t be feasible till the distant future, the concept is presently being tested in military based drones within the pentagon. Some people disagree with the notion of giving machines the competency to make autonomous decisions on the battlefield, particularly the use of lethal force, believing machines aren’t trustworthy and could result in greater loss of life. If we were to ask an ancient philosopher …show more content…

Therefore, it would be more expeditious and efficient to utilize a machine, that requires no training, to become an instant solider than to physically train someone for years supposing they might become an excellent soldier. When describing human inefficacy in learning new skills Plato said this “Can someone just pick up a shield, or instrument of war and immediately become a competent fighter in an infantry battle or whatever battle it may be, even though no other tool makes someone who just picks it up a craftsman or an athlete, or is even any service for him unless he has acquired knowledge of it and has had sufficient practice” (Plato 103-4). Plato makes a valid point, concluding not just anyone can become a solider without practice and being taught the same as how no one could become a master of any art. Machines don’t need practice like humans to become proficient at a skill, but are simply designed to be skilled at their own purpose from the start. Taking into account the amount of time taken to train a human rather than employ a machine further justifies that autonomous research should continue allowing machines to become the protectors of the republic, while humans could focus on improving their republic in their own way. These above human skills while making machines superior in combat would additionally make them more adept at saving

Get Access