preview

Position Paper

Decent Essays

Position Paper

I do think Lucy Donavan violated the UHD Honesty Policy because she obtained and used unauthorized material to prepare for her Intro to Politics midterm exam and was not honest in her glimpse of seeing the major essay topic.
Lucy obtained the midterm exam from the photocopying machine. The definition of “obtain” in the Merriam Webster Online Dictionary means “to hold on to, or possess.” In the case of Lucy she had possession of the test when she picked it up from the photocopy machine. This fact shows that Lucy did obtain the exam. The UHD Academic Honesty Section 2.2 labeled Academic Honesty Violations, Bullet 3, states that “obtaining and/ or using unauthorized material.” Lucy did violate this section of the policy. …show more content…

Sander’s box, slipped the exam into it, quickly scrawled a note (“I’m feeling sick and have gone home to bed-Lucy”.) This shows that Lucy has been dishonest twice about seeing the exam. The definition of “dishonest” from the Webster Pocket Dictionary says that dishonest means lacking honesty, deceitful; untrustworthy. Lucy has shown a lack of being honest.
Others may argue the fact that Lucy did turn herself in which showed that she did have a little honesty in her however, she did cheat and did not tell anyone about it until after she had did it. Instead of saying something before she took the exam, she didn’t and she had plenty of opportunities to do so. As such as after she saw the exam, while she was walking back to her dorm, when her manager called to check up on her and when Mr. Sander’s handed her her test. I also understand that some may also say that Lucy did not “obtain and use unauthorized material” due to the fact that she picked the paper up by accident and that Prof. Sander’s was not there to say it was unauthorized. Some may say the paper could have been assumed to be authorized due to the fact that Professor Sander use the same exact test that another Professor used last year in which other students had access to anyway however, Prof. Sanders did not tell her she could look at his exam and use the material to prepare for her test.
My position of the Academic Honesty Policy will affect a lot of people. Students might learn from the mistake of Lucy and

Get Access