preview

Protective Headgear's False Safety In Soccer

Decent Essays

Soccer, being the most popular sport across the nation, currently has millions of fans and approximately 25 million registered players in the United States alone (Niedfeldt). Since the early 2000’s and continually seventeen years later, concussions are among the highest sustained injury to soccer players. While the sport is increasing in popularity, fear of injuries is increasing as well. In response to the arising panic, several companies have come together in order to create, promote, and sell protective headgear to concerned soccer players and their parents. The creators of this gear claim that their products will reduce concussions and any negative neurocognitive effects in relation to heading balls in soccer. Although some believe that …show more content…

This belief that the players are safe when they are actually at risk could cause them to do things they would not have done otherwise. Ultimately, protective gear results in more harm than good. Niedfeldt supports the idea of this false security when he shares that as a result of wearing protective headgear in his study, women attacked the balls with more vigor and added to the impact due to the impression of safety (Niedfeldt). The results of this study show that individuals wearing protective headgear attack the soccer ball in a more dangerous manner that they would not have done without the false sense of safety that they feel because of this gear. Therefore, Niedfeldt’s trial demonstrates the fact that protective headgear has the potential to cause more damage to athletes than if they did not wear the gear. Often times, this phenomenon is known as the Superman effect which has been proven to occur when individuals feel more invincible than they really are. This ultimately causes reckless and aggressive behavior despite the fact that what these athletes are feeling is a false sense of security (Gray). Because of the superman effect, a soccer player with experience relating to protective headgear demonstrates that she obtained a concussion despite wearing protective headgear. Due to her experience, she illustrates that …show more content…

Although looking at a younger and an inferiorly qualified group of athletes could change the results of the study, younger soccer athletes play with a reduced aggression on the field. This lack of offensive drive ultimately reduces their chances of sustaining serious injuries. With little chance of serious injury, supplying or asking the young athletes or their parents to purchase protective headgear, on top of the existing costs of the sport, is unnecessary (Niedfeldt). In an effort to ease the minds of concerned individuals on the use of protective headgear among younger, less experienced athletes, players should take precautions in the form of alternatives.
As the popularity of soccer increases, controversy in relation to safety concerns continues to rise as well. Due to the ineffectiveness of protective headgear among soccer players, athletes should focus on alternatives to successfully prevent injuries. Concerned parents, coaches, and athletes should heightening rules and regulations and should properly evaluate the accuracy and effectiveness of the soccer gear (i.e., balls, gloves, etc.) being used in order to reduce chances of serious

Get Access