preview

René Lévesque's Memoir: The Structure Of Canadian History

Decent Essays

In my opinion, the best source was from René Lévesque’s Memoir and the worst source was from J.L Finlay and D.N. Sprague’s textbook “The structure of Canadian History”. René Lévesque’s memoir was and still is a good and reliable source because the limitations are meagre compared to the extensive validity and usefulness that is provided in the writing. René Lévesque is a credible source because he was the leader of the Parti Quebecois, which provided insight on the ins and outs of the political system and also allowed him to know any confidential information. He was also the voice of many individuals who were wronged. The content of the specific excerpt from his memoir reflects the resentfulness and anger Lévesque still has towards Trudeau, even after 20 years has passed. This emphasizes Lévesque’s strong and unchanged views towards Trudeau. “… without warrant, on the strength of suspicions, prejudice or pure idiocy…” , “Trudeau and the company …show more content…

Sprague’s textbook “The structure of Canadian History” was not a good source because of the bias towards Trudeau. Since this source was a textbook, it is unacceptable to deliver facts and credible information that is heavily influenced from personal bias. “…rather than issuing an apology for such overzealous police work, the Prime Minister boasted that separatism was “dead”.” This excerpt shows the extreme bias towards Trudeau and how incredible this source is. This source has many limitations that makes it unreliable and untrustworthy. As well as the limitations, the content and value are weary and questionable due to the heavy bias towards Trudeau. Another liability is the vagueness of the title “The structure of Canadian History.” This indicated that the textbook itself does not focus on the topic of the War Measures Act as comprehensive as the other sources. This source is the least useful source due to the heavy bias towards Trudeau in a textbook which should be providing unbiased and neutral

Get Access