preview

The Importance Of Animal Rights

Better Essays

The subject matter at hand, is whether animals should have rights or not? Following two opposing views by Tom Regan and Carl Cohen. However, before getting into more detail on their positions, what exactly is animal rights? As simple as it may seem, animal rights is exactly defined by its own term. Animal rights is simply moral privileges that should be considered for all non-human animals due to the fact that it is typically argued that these non-human animals encompass some form of emotional pain or pleasure. Looking at a historical aspect, the various views of animal rights in society have embodied a philosophical and legal progression. Animal rights has a role of significance in ethics because it has brought on a debate among …show more content…

Due to the fact that we would commonly think animals exist for our benefit we will make decisions without worrying about their pain or death. (Regan, p.361). Regan then presents the notion of assessing how the moral status of animals has been comprehended by those who oppose that animals have rights. He notes that people of this mind set usually come to the conclusion that “we have no duties directly to animals” (Regan, p.362). Furthermore, this leads him to proclaim that the more there is less sentimental value in these animal cases the more people perceive that they have no duties to the animals. Regan then argues that in a case where there is a mentally ill or young child torturing them would be viewed as wrong and unjust but, then why not viewed the same for animals. He proclaims we must admit that humans “have some duties directly to animals” (Regan, p.365). Regan then uses a utilitarian approach to help explain his point a little further as an analogy for what he refers to as the “cruelty-kindness view.” Which states that “we have a direct duty to be kind to animals and direct duty not to be cruel to them” (Regan, p.365). He notes that a utilitarian abides by two principles one that consists of equality and the other consisting of choosing the act that will

Get Access