The Miss En Scene Of National And International Fisheries

Better Essays

Now that we have deconstructed the basic premises and their place in the miss en scène of national and international fisheries, let us move to a more detailed analysis of the text’s subpoints examining the chapters for any underlying perspectives or evidence that significantly contribute to the arguments overall persuasiveness. The analysis that follows intends to capture each critical argument unfolding and developing itself, giving the reader a means to then discuss the contributions in regard to the circulation of wider discourse. Chapters 2-4: International regulation, political economy of regulation, and regulatory capture. We have already considered much of chapter 2 when regarding CPRs, the most important definition given by the …show more content…

Environmental economics provides an appropriate set of analytical tools to understand CPRs even though most regulation draws largely on the logics of population biology (Barkin p. 37). The discussion continues to recognise scientific based secretariat rule proposals being undermined by states final decision making power, and how sovereign representatives avoid advice in favour of free rider benefits.
The central argument of chapter 3 is a tension in the approaches to resource management; biologist (or anthropocentric view) are put premium on the value of ecosystems and biodiversity — sustainability perspective — while the econocentric view is focused on maximising present value of fishery resources without regard for the ‘unmonetised’ ecological utility. In a sense, multilateral cooperation finds a midpoint between these differing worldviews, but the former analysis of CPR enjoys privilege among stakeholders because it is more comfortably aligned with their interests — or perhaps until it is too late in which case ecological value has finally attained equal or greater economic status than the present value of fisheries. Applying these understandings to the overall argument that micro-regulation alone is insufficient, by considering the theoretical perspectives and various co-author studies as evidence, one finds

Get Access