preview

The Pros And Cons Of The Supreme Court

Decent Essays

Throughout history, the Supreme Court has acted as the ruler of many economic, social, and political issues that arise nationally. The Supreme Court is given the task of deciding the outcome of controversial arguments. In fact, the Supreme Court is the top court out of all other jurisdictions. In summary, a case starts out at a local level at trial court. Then, if the defendant does not like the decision, they can appeal their case to the appellate court. The appellate courts do not re-try cases or accept new evidence. They simply review the decisions and arguments from the original trial court. If the appellate courts don’t agree with the decision or find flukes in the case, then it will go to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court is the almighty …show more content…

The founding fathers created vague rules that are open to interpretation. There are some cases where the Constitution does not provide clear answers. For example, in the case of TLO vs New Jersey, a high school student was caught smoking in the bathroom. The principle searched her purse and discovered cigarettes and marijuana. This case made it to the Supreme Court over the interpretation of what constituted reasonable search and seizure. Ultimately, the Supreme Court makes decisions from petition and response. Four of the five judges must petition to go through with deciding a case. A response from either side of the case may be added for the Supreme Court judges to review. Once the case reaches the Supreme Court, each party is provided one hour to give their arguments. Judges may create notes in advanced to ask questions during the trial. After the trial, it can take weeks to months to reach a decision. Each judge is sent copies of case notes and knowledge of a variety of topics is required. Some judges are even influenced by the opinion of fellow judges and change their mind during the decision process. Once a decision is reached, the stage of painful accusation hits. Doubts of a decision can be expressed to a point when the court is attacked and there is unrest among the judicial system. Trial processes are complicated when it comes to the Supreme

Get Access