The Scarlet Ibis And Simon Birch Comparison Essay

Both Simon and Doodle have companions by their side throughout all or most of their lives. Simon had a best friend named Joe, who loved him for who he was. He did not mind having a best friend who had disabilities and was not the same as everyone else. For example, when Joe was riding his bike with Simon next to him in a cart, some men laughed at them. Simon and Joe did not let them phase their good moods and instead answered them with a rude remark and laughed themselves. This showed that Joe valued his friendship more than the acceptance of society. Brother, on the other hand, hated that his brother was different. He was always trying to change things about his younger sibling Doodle and make him more like everyone else:

Brother is a considerate character. He is considerate because when he found out that Doodle would live he changed his name from William Armstrong, which was a name that “only sounded

Even though Brother is being cruel and his motivation for acting that way is bad, it’s proven that brother still cares for Doodle. There are times when Brother is cruel to Doodle and this is present when Brother shows him his casket, “..telling him how we all had believed he would die.... Doodle studied the mahogany box for a long time, then said, ‘It’s not mine.’

Simon Birch and Doodle both had important brother figures in their life. Simon’s “brother” was Joe, his best friend that protected him and supported him through all situations. Joe protected him when people laughed at him, and stood by his side when Simon hit Joe’s mom, or was kicked out of the church. Joe was there for Simon, while Doodle’s brother was not. Doodle was a heavy burden on his brother: “He was a burden in many ways” (Hurst 431). For his brother was forced to lug Doodle with him everywhere he went, and Doodle was not a normal child or play friend for Brother to play with. Doodle was annoying and due to his

¨At six years old, when his brother is born, the narrator tells the reader that from the first, Doodle was "a disappointment." When he learns that Doodle is possibly mentally and physically challenged, the narrator begins his plan to kill his brother; however, his plans are soon discarded after Doodle smiles at him¨. (James Hurst) The main conflict of "The Scarlet Ibis" by James Hurst is Brother's inability to deal with Doodle's disabilities.

Although Simon and Doodle are similar , they are also more different than alike. Their different personalities are one of the main differences that affect who they are. Simon is very outspoken and does what he wants to do, while Doodle is

The brother’s criteria for being normal is very precise, as Doodle is expected to be indomitable. This creates conflict between Doodle and society, which is external conflict.

Older siblings feel obligated to take authority over their younger siblings. The narrator took the responsibility of teaching Doodle to develop into an ordinary boy; however, he supports Doodle out of selfishness. With this in mind, the narrator changes Doodle’s name from “William Armstrong” to Doodle because he believes Doodle is not strong enough to have that name. He believes “William Armstrong” only “sounds good only on a tombstone,” (595) so changing Doodle’s name was the kindest thing he could have done. Likewise, the narrator selfishly disobeys the doctor’s list of don'ts for Doodle because he doesn’t agree with Doodle’s limitations. In fact, the narrator hauls Doodle carelessly around cotton fields and whips him around corners on two wheels of the go-cart. As a result, the narrator decides to take the next step in teaching Doodle. As school approaches, Doodle falls behind on learning to run, swim, and climb. Therefore, the narrator decides to double his efforts and push Doodle even harder. “I made him swim until he turned blue and row until he couldn’t lift an oar. Wherever we

The older brother didn’t love Doodle at all he only did those things for Doodle

People being killed every day because they are different. The story “The Scarlet Ibis” by James Hurst is about a boy with a disorder that made him different from his family. But it's not okay to kill someone just for own Pride.

When Doodle is first born and after about three years he is being taught how to walk like normal people walk and his brother is not to thrilled about it he is just doing it because he does not want to drag him around and be dead weight so he does this so he does not have to deal with him as much.

The narrator always had strong opinions about Doodle. Ever since the day Doodle was born, the narrator’s pride was much too high for having him as a brother, saying, “he was born when I was six and was, from the outset, a disappointment.” Not even giving his brother a chance to grow up and prove himself. Since the narrator did not know how to handle having a

First, Of all Doodle was brave because once his brother tried to help him walk again he started to catch on and he started practicing with his brother to try to walk so that brother doesn't have to babysit him anymore. He also got treated bad by brother and he just took it so that made him brave for that. "I'm going to teach you to walk, Doodle," I said.I can't walk, Brother," he said. "Who says so?" I demanded."Mama, the doctor--everybody. This text evidence right here shows that doodle can’t walk and he tells himself that and that makes me think that that's how doodle described himself as weak and depends on others to help him out and another thing is that doodle said was. I heard Doodle, who had fallen behind, cry out, "Brother, Brother, don't leave me!Don’t leave me!” This is another text evidence that shows that doodle can't really do anything without his brother there for him. Or other people around him and that's why later in the story his brother tells you that he killed doodle so he didn't have to take care of him all of the time and then he regretted it.

The only thing that the Brother wanted was a sibling with which he could play with. But when Doodle arrived all of his hopes were shattered. As a result, he makes Doodle pay for it on many occasions. He makes him touch his own casket that was laying in the lay loft being reserved for

Doodle was running close behind Brother in fear of being left behind in the storm. Brother sped up a lot because he was mad at Doodle, mad that their training was not paying off and mad at himself for failing. Doodle could not keep up because of his weak heart. In contrast, Simon died saving other people’s lives and in return lost his, he believed he was God’s instrument and that God had a plan for him to do something important.