preview

The Shadow Reports Of India

Better Essays

For the purpose of this section, I’ve decided to look into the Shadow Reports of India (Executive Summary of the IV and V NGO Alternative Report on CEDAW of 2014), South Africa (South African Shadow Report on the Implementation of the Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination against Women of 2011), and Pakistan (INSERT REPORT HERE). I’ve chosen to do a cross analysis between how the women’s movements have responded to the actions taken by the government in regards to discrimination/equality and human trafficking/prostitution. I feel that the diverse nature of each of these countries will provide an interesting perspective on the similarities and differences in both governmental response and the women’s movement …show more content…

1). The primary critique made by the Shadow Report is the lack of proper implementation and enforcement of the legislative measures that have been passed for the protection of women in the aforementioned aspects. Overall, this critique is rather strong, as it provides factual evidence pertaining to cases where the legislative measures have consistently fallen short. The Shadow Report regards women from most areas including indigenous/tribal women, women of different social classes, women with different religious affiliations, women with disabilities, ETC. However, the report doesn’t seem to mention issues regarding women and sexuality, and this is where I believe the critique from the Shadow Report begins to fall a bit short. I recognize that with the magnitude of issues that women are facing in India, topics of sexuality may not take priority. It’s important to note that, in a report where nearly every type of women is regarded, it’s important to include topics of sexuality as well. Moreover, the Shadow Report falls short on making recommendations regarding how to solve these inequalities. Interestingly enough, the Shadow Report does mention human trafficking within article I briefly as a major concern for women in India. In contrast to the issues regarded in Article I, the CEDAW report has a rather extensive layout for issues pertaining to human trafficking and exploitation of women. The CEDAW report for India takes an

Get Access