preview

Turing Test Movie Analysis

Decent Essays

Ex-Machina features Caleb Smith, a young search-engine coder who is made to believe he’s won a contest at work. The prize was to spend a week with company executive, Nathan Bateman, who has been living off the grid in a research facility. Although Caleb thought he was going to go to have fun in a vacation retreat, but ends up finding out he's been called there only to be part of Nathan's research. While explaining his research, Nathan asks Caleb if he knows what the Turing Test is? Caleb knows that this is a test to differentiate between a man and a machine and if not possible the machine is considered intelligent, automatically he assumed Nathan was creating an artificial intelligence. Nathan reveals to Caleb that he has been brought for the …show more content…

If the questioner couldn’t tell the difference between the texts, the test would be passed, meaning the machine has intelligence. Even Though Caleb isn't doing the original Turing test, since he is viewing Ava’s actions, as she answers the questions. “For Turing, there is nothing more to being intelligent than being able to use language as we do(taken from Doing Philosophy, Lewis Vaughn).” This states that Ava is intelligent since it’s stated in the movie that she is born with language and demonstrates it throughout the sessions with Caleb. Although Ava can clearly pass the Turing test without a doubt, John Searle denies that it takes any intelligence to pass the Turing test. A thought experiment, called Searle’s Chinese Room, where a human is put in the computer's spot and given an input in Chinese with no knowledge of that language, just a rulebook which translates the symbols into english. The job of that person is to give an output that makes sense to the input given by using the rulebook. Like a computer or this case Ava, the human put to the test manipulated the symbols, but added no meaning to the symbol. According to Searle, “computers manipulate symbols on the basis of their physical features or form, whereas humans manipulate symbols on the basis of their meaning or content(taken from Doing Philosophy, Lewis …show more content…

Ava tries gaining her freedom by playing on Caleb’s human responses, just like humans would. Although many would argue that Ava is showing consciousness throughout her sessions with Nathan, they're wrong since, “consciousness implies to inner subjectivity, a personal world separated from one’s external actions(taken from Doing Philosophy, Lewis Vaughn).” This implies that if Ava did have conscious we wouldn’t tell because we can't judge that from her external actions but her inner subjectivity, which is something private to her. So there’s no proof that Ava has true consciousness, since we don't know what Ava’s inner world is like, for all we know Ava has mastered to simulate humanness. We get a much clearer notion of this in the movie “Blade Runner” when they use the Voight-Kampff test, a test design to measure body responses to distinguish from human or computer. This means that in the future, a world where androids are virtually indistinguishable from humans, the way of determining humanness are by viewing the reactions of the subject, towards virtual scenarios. This highlights how the human body may reveal things that remain unconscious, proving that Ava’s “consciousness” resulted in a super advanced program created by Nathan to imitated

Get Access