Consider an aqueous solution of N = 1022 dye molecules separated from pure solvent by a movable, semipermeable plug: Lmax In class we estimated the probability distribution P(L) x (L) for finding the plug at a distance L from the top of the solution, where 2(L) x LN is the number of ways available space above the plug. arrange N solutes in the If no external force is applied to the plug, we argued, the maximum value of P(L) should occur when L takes on its largest possible value, Lmax. Here you will estimate the size of typical fluctuations in plug position, AL Lmax - L. (a) What displacement ALtyp gives a probability (per unit length) equal to ten percent of the max- imum? In other words, solve the equation P(Lmax - ALıyp) = 0.1P(Lmax). For this purpose use a Taylor expansion of In 2 around Lmax To determine a numerical value for ALtyp, take the container's height to be Lmax = 10 cm. (b) Thermodynamics concerns the behavior of average macroscopic quantities, such as the length L in our dye solution, and neglects fluctuations about mean values. Comment on the validity of this approach in light of your answer to part (a).

Modern Physics
3rd Edition
ISBN:9781111794378
Author:Raymond A. Serway, Clement J. Moses, Curt A. Moyer
Publisher:Raymond A. Serway, Clement J. Moses, Curt A. Moyer
Chapter11: Molecular Structure
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 12P
icon
Related questions
Question
V7
Consider an aqueous solution of N = 1022 dye molecules separated from pure solvent by a movable,
semipermeable plug:
Lmax
In class we estimated the probability distribution P(L) x 2(L) for finding the plug at a distance L
from the top of the solution, where 2(L) x LN is the number of ways to arrange N solutes in the
available space above the plug.
If no external force is applied to the plug, we argued, the maximum value of P(L) should occur when
L takes on its largest possible value, Lmax: Here you will estimate the size of typical fluctuations in
plug position, AL = Lmax - L.
(a) What displacement ALtyp gives a probability (per unit length) equal to ten percent of the max-
imum? In other words, solve the equation P(Lmax – ALtyp) = 0.1P(Lmax). For this purpose
use a Taylor expansion of In? around Lmax. To determine a numerical value for ALtyp, take the
container's height to be Lmax = 10 cm.
(b) Thermodynamics concerns the behavior of average macroscopic quantities, such as the length L
in our dye solution, and neglects fluctuations about mean values. Comment on the validity of this
approach in light of your answer to part (a).
Transcribed Image Text:Consider an aqueous solution of N = 1022 dye molecules separated from pure solvent by a movable, semipermeable plug: Lmax In class we estimated the probability distribution P(L) x 2(L) for finding the plug at a distance L from the top of the solution, where 2(L) x LN is the number of ways to arrange N solutes in the available space above the plug. If no external force is applied to the plug, we argued, the maximum value of P(L) should occur when L takes on its largest possible value, Lmax: Here you will estimate the size of typical fluctuations in plug position, AL = Lmax - L. (a) What displacement ALtyp gives a probability (per unit length) equal to ten percent of the max- imum? In other words, solve the equation P(Lmax – ALtyp) = 0.1P(Lmax). For this purpose use a Taylor expansion of In? around Lmax. To determine a numerical value for ALtyp, take the container's height to be Lmax = 10 cm. (b) Thermodynamics concerns the behavior of average macroscopic quantities, such as the length L in our dye solution, and neglects fluctuations about mean values. Comment on the validity of this approach in light of your answer to part (a).
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 3 steps with 3 images

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Angular speed, acceleration and displacement
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, physics and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Modern Physics
Modern Physics
Physics
ISBN:
9781111794378
Author:
Raymond A. Serway, Clement J. Moses, Curt A. Moyer
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
University Physics Volume 2
University Physics Volume 2
Physics
ISBN:
9781938168161
Author:
OpenStax
Publisher:
OpenStax