A Study of Prisoners and Guards in a Simulated Prison Essay

2777 Words 12 Pages
A Study of Prisoners and Guards in a Simulated Prison

Background

This study was funded by the US Navy, as it and the US Marine Corps
were interested in finding out the causes of conflict between guards
and prisoners in the naval prisons. Attempts to explain the violent
and brutal conditions often found in prisons had previously used
dispositional attribution. That is, that the state of the prison is
due to the nature of the prison guards and the prisoners.

For example, it had been argued that prison guards bring to their jobs
a particular ‘guard mentality’ and are therefore attracted to the job
as they are already sadistic and insensitive people. Whereas prisoners
are individuals who have no
…show more content…
Either prisoner or guard. The dependent variable is the resulting
behaviour.

The study can also be described as a simulation as it was attempting
to create a prison like environment.

Data collected were combinations of both quantitative and qualitative
data. The main data though was qualitative and was obtained using
video, audiotape and direct observation.

The participants were respondents to a newspaper advertisement, which
asked for male volunteers to participate in a psychological study of
‘prison life’ in return for payment of $15 per day.

The 75 respondents completed a questionnaire about their family
background, physical and mental health, prior experiences and
attitudinal tendencies with respect to psychopathology and any
involvement in crime.

Based on the results of the tests 24 men were selected. These 24 were
judged to be the most physically and mentally stable, most mature, and
least involved in antisocial behaviours. The participants were
described as “normal, healthy male college students who were
predominantly middle class and white.” The 24 participants did not
know each other prior to the study.

A simulated prison was built in the basement of the psychology
building at Stanford University. The simulated prison comprised of:

* Three small…