preview

Achican American Identity Case Study

Decent Essays

What? Why does Lorena resist identifying herself as a Latina or a Chicana? What are the discourses that stigmatize these identities? To Nelda, what is the difference between being Chicana and being Mexican American? What are the discourses that surround each identity? What experiences have informed the ways in which Nelda and Lorena understand their identities? What does Lorena mean when she refers to her “job as a human being”? How does this perspective shape the way she understands her identity?
Have you ever been asked what’s your race or ethnicity? Well I have, and it’s a strange question to answer personally. When someone asks me that I have to wait and ponder as to why in the world would one would be asking such a strange question. I …show more content…

That is a question that has several answers, but in Lorena’s case she redefines what it means to be Mexican American in the US by working hard to better herself and her life. An example of Lorena bettering herself is when she set out to get a job that would help her advance in her life instead of a job that is stereotypically done by immigrants, “… in my situation, Hispanic people, we don’t get office jobs. I was sure I needed to go get a job at another meat market, or maybe helping clean houses, or babysitting” (Lorena, 195). Even though she faced so much self-doubt about what she was capable of doing, she went and explored her possibilities. That was just one way that undocumented immigrants work harder to redefine being Mexican American in the US. In the Valenzuela piece, it is more difficult to prove how Nelda was trying to change what it meant to be Mexican American. Although, the author does provide her own insight as to how Nelda makes that change to redefining herself, “the fact that she bore at least some of the emblems of Americanized speech, dress, and interpersonal skills is a side note to a more central awakening within her that helps explain her rapid transformation into a Chicana against the historical and institutional odds of her doing so” (Nelda,

Get Access