preview

Analysis Of The Short Story 'Gentlemen, Your Verdict'

Decent Essays

‘Gentlemen, Your Verdict’ Essay Draft In the short story ‘Gentlemen, Your Verdict’, by Michael Bruce, Lieutenant-Commander Oram was forced to make the complicated decision of saving five members of his crew, or allowing everyone to die due to a mine accident that damaged their submarine. Commander Oram made the right decision to a great extent due to there not being a way out of his situation that did not result in the death of his crew, he did not inform the 14 crew members that were to die, that they were being killed, and he spared all but one of his married crew members. By choosing to only kill 14 members of his crew and himself, Oram was still able to save some. When Oram was informed of the outside situation, being that the crew was not to be rescued until up to seven days, as “their tender got some of the blast (from the mine), the next nearest one was in dry dock, four hundred miles away, with half her plates off, and the planes were grounded until the storm ended” (par.26). The crew could survive for a maximum of two days, and there was no achievable way to save everyone. Due to his circumstances, Oram was forced to make a quick decision whether to save five members of his crew, or let all 20 men die. He did not have time to weigh every possibility as there was limited time and air in the submarine. Consequently, Oram decided to save five, and kill the other crew members. However, Oram attempted to find a way to rescue all of them, as he called the shore station several times asking if “it was absolutely certain, then?” (par.31) that there was no way for them to be rescued by an external party, just to guarantee that there was no way out of the situation that did not mean the death of all, or the majority of his crew. By choosing to save the five, he made the logical choice, the choice that virtually everyone would prefer as it is obvious that saving five people and letting 15 people die is better than letting all 20 people die, just coming from a math standpoint. Considering that Oram saved 5 members of his crew, he had to kill 14 members and himself. Lieutenant-Commander Oram made the choice not to tell the 14 crew members that were to be killed. Consequently, he could control the situation

Get Access