preview

Comparing Eleven And David Talamántez On The Last Day Of Second Grade

Decent Essays

Imagine one of those days where your teacher or parent will just not listen to whatever you say even if one knows a hundred percent that you stand correct. Imagine if you have a disease where your brain function differently and your teachers batter you with criticisms. Two students, Rachel and David experience these hardships. Rachel from the short story, “Eleven,” and David from the poem, “David Talamántez on the Last Day of Second Grade,” share similarities including dealing with authority, however, the two students deal with their obstacles with completely contrasting methods. In “Eleven,” Rachel, an intellectual eleven-year-old girl, becomes falsely labeled as the owner of a red sweater. Throughout the story, Rachel experiences a rollercoaster …show more content…

Price, David accepts himself, ignoring his teachers’ criticism. For example, when Mrs. Price states, “Of course it’s yours. I remember you wearing it once,” Rachel thinks that Mrs. Price stands correct. Instead of standing up for herself even though Rachel knew the sweater did not belong to her, Rachel submitted to the idea Mrs. Price, an elder and a teacher, has the authority and remains right. On the other hand, when David receives his papers back with poor grades and negative comments, he crosses the red ink out and writes “Yes! David, yes!” instead. David knew that he had worked to the best of his abilities. He erased and rewrote numerous times, trying to manage his dyslexia, however the teacher criticized him for his efforts. Contrast, Rachel thinks, “Maybe because I’m skinny, maybe because she doesn’t like me…” when her classmate suggests the sweater belongs to Rachel. Rachel automatically feels insecure. Whereas, David does not have an ounce of insecurity. On the last day, as well as throwing his papers in the air, David also shouts, “David! David, yes!” Never once in “David Talamántez on the Last Day of Second Grade” does David show a sign of

Get Access