preview

Comparing Hamlet And Tennant's Hamlet

Decent Essays

Ophelia’s Madness In Branagh’s Hamlet and Tennant’s Hamlet

The play Hamlet, by William Shakespeare, is the second most filmed play in the world after Cinderella (“Hamlet: The Facts”). Many people have attempted to re-create the Shakespearian tragedy on-screen but few have been able to do successfully. The extent of Ophelia’s madness is controversial, and is often portrayed differently in every movie. The 2009 David Tennant version of Hamlet and the 1996 Kenneth Branagh version of Hamlet are two movies that both share similarities and have differences in the use of actors, setting, and costumes to emphasize Ophelia’s madness.

The selection of actresses based on acting techniques made an impact in the way Ophelia’s madness was expressed. In the Tennant film, Mariah Gale was selected to play Ophelia. Gale’s mixture of cheeriness and despair brought an eerie feeling to her mad scenes, allowing the viewer to decide the extent of her madness. Her singing sounded delirious and frantic, this effectively created a broken image for herself. …show more content…

The Tennant film uses a modern black room with a shatter mirror for Ophelia’s confrontation with Claudius and Gertrude in Act four, Scene five. This causes the mood of the scene to be dark, and the shattered mirror seems to parallel the fractured state of Ophelia. The darkness of the room also contrasts with Ophelia’s white dress and makes her the center of attention for the viewers. The Branagh version uses a checkered ballroom for Ophelia’s first appearance as a madwoman in Act 4, Scene 5. The room does not set a particular mood for the scene. Unlike the Tennant version, the Branagh movie includes scenes with a distressed Ophelia being held in a padded asylum, and also a scene of her drowning in clear water. In this case, the setting directly tells the audience that Ophelia is insane, but in the Tennant version the mysterious room give the audience an opportunity

Get Access