preview

Comparison Of The Youngstown City School District

Decent Essays

The two district I chose to compare to the Youngstown City School District are Canton School and Mansfield School Districts. As I was going through the report cards I was not surprised at the similarities between Canton Schools and Youngstown, due to the fact that they are both city school districts. However, I was surprised with the scores from the Mansfield’s report card, and I am not sure why?
Below is a breakdown/comparison of the three school districts:

As I compiled this report looking at the overall report card these three districts are very similar. They all received an overall “F” on their State Report Card but there were a few differences that stood out to me. First is the K-3 Literacy, Youngstown received a …show more content…

In YCSD it seems that Students with Disabilities are the students who move the most, while CCSD has both Limited English and the Hispanic students are the most mobile and MCSD the Limited English population that is most mobile.

When looking at District Report Cards all we usually hear about is student data, not realizing that there is also teacher data reported in this document. Looking over the data as a whole the schools are pretty similar in teacher data. Attendance was at between 93% and 94%, while teacher-students ratio per 1000 students was lower than the state average in all schools. Teacher’s average pay was within $5000.00, MCSD was the lowest at $52,000.00 and CCSD being the highest at $57,000.00. Looking at teacher and principal evaluations YCSD and MCSD had no teachers with an Effective evaluation, the highest percentage of teachers fell under Accomplished in evaluations. As for principals YCSD and MCSD principals were either Accomplished or Skilled, the majority were Skilled, in all Districts. As for CCSD, they had no one Accomplished, but they did have Developing and Effective.

Finance was the final section of the report I looked at and YCSD spends the most per pupil, over $11,000 while the other two districts between $8800 and $9400 and about 65% of that are spent on classrooms.

Looking through these report cards from an administrative “lens”, I was looking at more than just the final grade, I looked deeper into the subgroups

Get Access