preview

Dr. Khabeer: A Theoretical Analysis

Decent Essays

Recent events have given rise to dialogues of the systematic inequalities Black and Muslim communities face in the United States. From events like the 2013 shooting of Trayvon Martin to the more recent ban of individuals from seven Muslim majority countries, it is evident that there exists a hierarchy within the boundaries of the United States that advertently hurts those of “color.” At the crossroads of religious discrimination and racism, Black Muslims are victimized in part due to the parallel racial norms they are subject to. Through the aesthetics of dandyism, some Black Muslims in America aim to challenge those US racial hierarchies. Dr. Su’ad Abdul Khabeer examines how the symbolic sartorial practices of dandyism in Black American Muslim …show more content…

Khabeer states that Black Muslims fall short to the “Politics of Pious Respectability,” which “describes a performative landscape that conflates certain set of cultural specificities with normative notions of Muslim piety, privileging culturally contingent practices from the ‘Islamic East’ from the Muslim practice that originates elsewhere” (Khabeer, 2017). She establishes the existence of the concept using an anecdote of Abd al-Karim, a well-versed Muslim who lost his privilege to lead prayers in his community after he changed his style of dress to another individual who dressed the part of a “Muslim” but was much less educated. Many Black Muslims believed that their valued Hip-Hop aesthetics were untenable if they wanted to be seen as authentic and authoritative Muslims (Khabeer, 2017). In addition, if dressing the part (i.e. Salwar Khameez) is enough to create imaginary ties to the “Islamic East,” then Black Muslims must be at a disadvantage in obtaining religious authority in more diverse US Muslim societies, which may have individuals that are linked to the “Islamic East” simply through heritage. Therefore, discriminations within the Muslim Ummah lead to the indigenous/immigrant divide between Black American Muslims and American Muslims of Arab and South Asian descent, as the former tried to imitate the latter due to lacking cultural roots (Khabeer, 2017; Fischer & Abedi, 1990: 324). However, as Bowen notes, it is no longer plausible to equate Islam …show more content…

A simple interpretive controversy of a verse from the Holy Book of Islam, “O you who believe, obey God and obey the Messenger and the holders of authority from among you” (The Quran, Al-Nisa 4.59), led to the most well known Sunni/Shia split in Islamic history, leading to several different Islamic cultures across the globe today. The “holders of authority” part of the verse is quite contested; in the Shi’ite interpretation, the Imam is the current holder of authority (Fischer & Abedi, 1990: 131). In the Shi’ite perspective, there is a literal ancestry that can be linked from the Imam directly back to Prophet Muhammad. Thus, religious authority, as obtained through the Shi’ite perspective is indicative of a similar concept to the “Politics of Pious Respectability.” The contestation of the verse, in tandem with the Black Muslims use of dandyism, provides evidence that “culture is contested, temporal and emergent” (Clifford & Marcus, 1986). Here, we see a movement away from the traditional Islamic and/or culturally significant Hip-Hop outfit towards a new style and thus a new culture and identity emerges. Individuals like Abd al-Karim use dandyism as a form of resistance “to signify on Arab and South Asian US American Muslim hegemonies and declare themselves to be firm Muslims, even if they are urbanized, working class Black

Get Access