preview

Is Vigilantism Helpful to Society in Its Attempts to Enforce Justice and Eradicate Crime?

Best Essays

Aseela Shamim Haque
2015-02-0199
Writing and Communication
Section 6
Aqila Zaman
9th May, 2012

Is vigilantism helpful to society in its attempts to enforce justice and eradicate crime?

Suppose a person feels that his neighborhood bully is targeting him. The police are ignoring his complaints and he is tired of the harassment. He sees on television that vigilantes like Batman are taking matters into their own hands and standing up to the oppressors. He decides to do the same. He faces his enemy and a heated argument ensues. A couple of punches are thrown and before he knows it the skirmish erupts into an aggressive brawl. He channels all his frustration and keeps throwing punches; one after the other. In a little while, his …show more content…

Sometimes once those groups have the ability to exert their influence in the society, the division between right and wrong becomes hazy. This was evident in the case of the Baldknobbers. They were a vigilante group initiated by Nathaniel N. Kinney in Taney County, South West Missouri. After the Cold War, Missouri was plagued with lawlessness, a plunging economy and a general break down of the society. In such an environment, Kinney decided to form a vigilante group to restore some law in the land. By April 1885, the organization had become nearly 200 people strong. They made a public display of their strength when a 100 of them broke into the Taney County Jail and abducted Frank and Tubal Taylor; the brothers had wounded the storekeeper of a shop whose owner happened to be a Bald Knobbler. The two were then transported to the south of Forsyth and hanged. The violence escalated as the group would whip or brand alleged thieves, arsonists and robbers. Assault, disturbance of peace or destruction of property would result in the hanging of the offender. Many criminals were also beaten to death. Some of the Bald Knobbers started using their power for their own selfish means. They would pursue and threaten people who owed them money or owned land they yearned for. The violence rose to such extents that men were flogged for supporting the wrong candidate in the election (“The fierce Missouri Bald Knobbers”). Thus, it is very

Get Access