preview

SB Reform

Good Essays

The concept of SBM was the result of the call for a more flexible and responsive control structure. The hope was that this reform would improve the productivity of schools, school effectiveness, and student achievement (Odden and Wohlstetter, 1992). When analyzing the level of success that SBM reform had on the field of education, one quickly can identify that this reform goes beyond the surface level of purely symbolic reform. Rather, the problem that this reform was attempting to solve was both historical and political in nature. SBM reform is an example of attempted organizational change that demanded a deep look at authority and power. Since public schools are public institutions, institutional discourse can explain how it relates and shares …show more content…

While there are some pockets of success, the vast majority of site-based teams are slowly dissolving. For example, Kansas continues to maintain the legislative requirement (KS 72-6439(d)), where this statute instituted an accreditation system that has a provision requiring all schools to establish a site-council as part of their accreditation. However, across the country most SBM teams have relatively small attendance rates, with the percentages decreasing as students advance through their schooling years (Holloway, 2000). SBM teams report that their actual decision-making is minimal and often come across as a meager attempt to pacify parents in a false-appearance of making parents feel like they have a …show more content…

SBM is, however, a potentially valuable tool for engaging the talents and enthusiasm of far more of a school's stakeholders than traditional, top-down governance systems. Moreover, once in place, SBM holds the promise of enabling schools to better address students' needs. This promise is more likely, however, if a "high-involvement" model of SBM is followed. This model envisions teachers and principals being trained and empowered to make decisions related to management and performance; having access to information to inform such decisions; and being rewarded for their accomplishments.
Ultimately, impact evaluations of SBM programs, or any other kind of program, are important because they can demonstrate whether or not the program has accomplished its objectives. Furthermore, these evaluations can identify ways to improve the design of the program. For example, they can establish whether the population that is benefiting from the program is the intended target population. These evaluations can also make successful reforms politically sustainable and can create a consensus on a plan for reforming an unsuccessful program. The recent evidence from impact evaluations of SBM programs is

Get Access