preview

Essay Software Piracy beyond the Street Corner

Better Essays

Software Piracy beyond the Street Corner

On January 23, 2003, the world’s leading computer networking equipment maker Cisco Systems, headquartered in San Jose California, filed a lawsuit against China-based Huawei Technologies and its United States subsidiaries Huawei America and FutureWei Technologies. In the lawsuit, Cisco alleged that Huawei stole intellectual property by copying its Internet Operating System (IOS) software and its copyrighted user manuals. Cisco also claimed that Huawei infringed on its patents. After numerous failed attempts to resolve these complaints directly with Huawei, which included a cease and desist letter to one of Huawei’s United Kingdom distributors, Cisco decided that a lawsuit was necessary to …show more content…

Huawei also pitched the fact that any Cisco-trained engineer could operate the Quidway router with ease. Cisco’s rise to the leadership in networking equipment and technology was the result of many years of diligent, hard work and creativity. Cisco holds several patents, copyrights, and trade secrets that are critical to its success. Huawei, on the other hand, chose to make shortcuts and had complete disregard for the sanctity and legality of intellectual property. In fact, Huawei’s Vice President confessed that “all the world’s leading equipment suppliers are our learning modules.”[1] Can Huawei’s belief in “learning” from their competitors and Cisco’s belief that Huawei stole and copied intellectual property be attributed to a differing ethical perspective due to culture? We will discuss this in Section 3.

Cisco claims against Huawei involved copying IOS source code, copying technical documentation and user manuals, copying command line interface (CLI) and screen displays, and patent infringement.

Source Code/Software

Cisco’s proprietary software that enables routers to interact with each other and direct traffic across the Internet is called IOS (Internet Operating System). Huawei’s competitive operating system is called VRP (Versatile Routing Platform). Cisco claimed that VPR contains identical text strings, bugs, and file names that could not simply be coincidental. Text strings are unique sentences inserted into the source code by the programmer as a

Get Access