preview

Vanilla Ice Case

Good Essays

On July 2, 1990, Vanilla Ice announced his new hip-hop single “Ice Ice Baby,” which was also set to be released on his debut album To the Extreme. The opening bass line for his single sounds astonishingly identical to the bass line found in the collaborative work of David Bowie and Queen, titled “Under Pressure,” which was released just under nine years prior on October 26, 1981. Vanilla Ice had not requested to exploit the rights before producing or releasing the song. and by proclaiming that he did the songwriting and production for the rest of the song, Vanilla Ice made himself directly liable for the infringement. The legal counsels of both David Bowie and Queen worked quickly to form a legal team in order sue Vanilla Ice for copyright …show more content…

He paid an undisclosed amount of money, which was settled outside of the court, in royalties to both David Bowie and Queen (more specifically, to Freddie Mercury). Both parties also received songwriting credits on “Ice Ice Baby” (Carlbom 2013; Denham, 2016; Hubbard, 2017). According to Vanilla Ice himself, he never even talked to David Bowie or the members of Queen about reaching this agreement. He stated that he had his legal counsel concern themselves with bargaining in this ordeal, and this lawsuit just was not a worrisome situation to him (“Vanilla Ice,” …show more content…

Vanilla Ice willfully sampled “Under Pressure” without their permission, which is a direct offense of copyright law. This type of infringement is equatable to stealing property (Moser & Slay, 2014). After a stern confrontation from the collective legal team, Vanilla Ice’s initial defense was incredibly weak: author J. Runtagh, for the Rolling Stone, states his defense makes this one of the most “hilarious” copyright cases ever. One could argue that a more appropriate course of action would be to take Vanilla Ice to court and have him formally charged with copyright infringement, as well as not allowing him to purchase all the publishing rights. Vanilla Ice’s nonchalant attitude toward the infringement lends one to believe he does not understand or care about his actions. Moreover, allowing David Bowie and Queen to keep their share of songwriting royalties and publishing royalties serves more appropriately as a settlement due to the fact that it allows for income to be pursued as long as the rights are

Get Access