Argument 5: Herbal Cure for a Headache? Julie was suffering from a very bad headache the morning she was scheduled to take a major exam. Her friend, Anna, suggested that she drink an herbal tea before going to class to treat the headache. Julie decided she might as well take it because the Tylenol she'd taken earlier that day "didn't seem to be working". So, she drank the tea, which was very pleasant tasting, and by the time the test was over, her headache was gone. Julie told her friend that the herbal tea was amazing because it had definitely cured her headache. 10. What is/are the premise/s of the claim made by Julie? a. Julie had a bad headache. b. Julie drank an herbal tea c. Julie's headache went away d. The herbal tea cured the headache. e. All of the above are premises f. A. B. and C are premises

Essentials of Pharmacology for Health Professions
7th Edition
ISBN:9781305441620
Author:WOODROW
Publisher:WOODROW
ChapterCRE2: Comprehensive Review Exam For Part 2
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 15CEP2
icon
Related questions
Question
100%
11. What is/are the conclusions/s of the claim made by Julie?
a. Julie had a bad headache,
b. Julie drank an herbal tea
c. Julie's headache went away
d. The herbal tea cured the headache.
e. All of the above are premises
f A B. and C are premises
12. This argument is:
a. valid and sound
d. not valid and not sound
b. valid, but not sound
c. not valid but sound
e. a strong/reasonable argument
13. What fallacy has Julie committed?
a. Appeal to tradition
b. Appeal to the masses
c. Moving the goalposts
d. Mistaking correlation for causation
Transcribed Image Text:11. What is/are the conclusions/s of the claim made by Julie? a. Julie had a bad headache, b. Julie drank an herbal tea c. Julie's headache went away d. The herbal tea cured the headache. e. All of the above are premises f A B. and C are premises 12. This argument is: a. valid and sound d. not valid and not sound b. valid, but not sound c. not valid but sound e. a strong/reasonable argument 13. What fallacy has Julie committed? a. Appeal to tradition b. Appeal to the masses c. Moving the goalposts d. Mistaking correlation for causation
Argument 5: Herbal Cure for a Headache?
Julie was suffering from a very bad headache the morning she was scheduled to take a
major exam. Her friend, Anna, suggested that she drink an herbal tea before going to
class to treat the headache. Julie decided she might as well take it because the Tylenol
she'd taken earlier that day "didn't seem to be working". So, she drank the tea, which
was very pleasant tasting, and by the time the test was over, her headache was gone.
Julie told her friend that the herbal tea was amazing because it had definitely cured her
headache.
10. What is/are the premise/s of the claim made by Julie?
a. Julie had a bad headache.
b. Julie drank an herbal tea
c. Julie's headache went away
d. The herbal tea cured the headache.
e All of the above are premises
f A. B. and C are premises
Transcribed Image Text:Argument 5: Herbal Cure for a Headache? Julie was suffering from a very bad headache the morning she was scheduled to take a major exam. Her friend, Anna, suggested that she drink an herbal tea before going to class to treat the headache. Julie decided she might as well take it because the Tylenol she'd taken earlier that day "didn't seem to be working". So, she drank the tea, which was very pleasant tasting, and by the time the test was over, her headache was gone. Julie told her friend that the herbal tea was amazing because it had definitely cured her headache. 10. What is/are the premise/s of the claim made by Julie? a. Julie had a bad headache. b. Julie drank an herbal tea c. Julie's headache went away d. The herbal tea cured the headache. e All of the above are premises f A. B. and C are premises
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Homeostasis
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, biology and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Essentials of Pharmacology for Health Professions
Essentials of Pharmacology for Health Professions
Nursing
ISBN:
9781305441620
Author:
WOODROW
Publisher:
Cengage
Curren'S Math For Meds: Dosages & Sol
Curren'S Math For Meds: Dosages & Sol
Nursing
ISBN:
9781305143531
Author:
CURREN
Publisher:
Cengage
Basic Clinical Lab Competencies for Respiratory C…
Basic Clinical Lab Competencies for Respiratory C…
Nursing
ISBN:
9781285244662
Author:
White
Publisher:
Cengage
Human Physiology: From Cells to Systems (MindTap …
Human Physiology: From Cells to Systems (MindTap …
Biology
ISBN:
9781285866932
Author:
Lauralee Sherwood
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Human Biology (MindTap Course List)
Human Biology (MindTap Course List)
Biology
ISBN:
9781305112100
Author:
Cecie Starr, Beverly McMillan
Publisher:
Cengage Learning