Name Paper Works Inc. makes paper products and dumps its waste into the Fish River. The waste has harmed the productivity of the river's brown trout fishery, angering anglers that love to flyfish the river. Downstream from Paper Works Inc. is a fishing resort and guide service, Fish Ranch, who has experienced a significant decrease in profits due to waste dumped into the river by Paper Works. Inc. Suppose that Fish Ranch sues Paper Works Inc. on behalf of all anglers harmed by Paper Works Inc., and that the actual damages are $50 million each year. A. Suppose that the benefit to Paper Works Inc. of dumping the waste into the river is $75 million annually. Is it efficient for Paper Works Inc. to dump the waste into the river? How about if the benefit to Paper Works Inc. is $25 million? Explain. B. The court orders Paper Works Inc. to pay damages of $50 million so that all the anglers hurt by the pollution are compensated. a. What will Paper Works Inc. do if its benefit from dumping waste into the river is $75 million? Is this outcome efficient? b. How about if the benefit to Paper Works Inc. is $25 million? Is this outcome efficient? C. Is part B an application of the Normative Coase Theorem or the Normative Hobbes Theorem? Explain. D. What practical problem do courts run into when imposing damages in situations like this?
Name Paper Works Inc. makes paper products and dumps its waste into the Fish River. The waste has harmed the productivity of the river's brown trout fishery, angering anglers that love to flyfish the river. Downstream from Paper Works Inc. is a fishing resort and guide service, Fish Ranch, who has experienced a significant decrease in profits due to waste dumped into the river by Paper Works. Inc. Suppose that Fish Ranch sues Paper Works Inc. on behalf of all anglers harmed by Paper Works Inc., and that the actual damages are $50 million each year. A. Suppose that the benefit to Paper Works Inc. of dumping the waste into the river is $75 million annually. Is it efficient for Paper Works Inc. to dump the waste into the river? How about if the benefit to Paper Works Inc. is $25 million? Explain. B. The court orders Paper Works Inc. to pay damages of $50 million so that all the anglers hurt by the pollution are compensated. a. What will Paper Works Inc. do if its benefit from dumping waste into the river is $75 million? Is this outcome efficient? b. How about if the benefit to Paper Works Inc. is $25 million? Is this outcome efficient? C. Is part B an application of the Normative Coase Theorem or the Normative Hobbes Theorem? Explain. D. What practical problem do courts run into when imposing damages in situations like this?
Business Its Legal Ethical & Global Environment
10th Edition
ISBN:9781305224414
Author:JENNINGS
Publisher:JENNINGS
Chapter11: Environmental Regulation And Sustainability
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1QAP
Related questions
Question
Transcribed Image Text:Name
Paper Works Inc. makes paper products and dumps its waste into the Fish River. The waste has harmed the productivity
of the river's brown trout fishery, angering anglers that love to flyfish the river. Downstream from Paper Works Inc. is a
fishing resort and guide service, Fish Ranch, who has experienced a significant decrease in profits due to waste dumped
into the river by Paper Works. Inc. Suppose that Fish Ranch sues Paper Works Inc. on behalf of all anglers harmed by
Paper Works Inc., and that the actual damages are $50 million each year.
A. Suppose that the benefit to Paper Works Inc. of dumping the waste into the river is $75 million annually. Is it
efficient for Paper Works Inc. to dump the waste into the river? How about if the benefit to Paper Works Inc. is
$25 million? Explain.
B. The court orders Paper Works Inc. to pay damages of $50 million so that all the anglers hurt by the pollution are
compensated.
a. What will Paper Works Inc. do if its benefit from dumping waste into the river is $75 million? Is this
outcome efficient?
b. How about if the benefit to Paper Works Inc. is $25 million? Is this outcome efficient?
C. Is part B an application of the Normative Coase Theorem or the Normative Hobbes Theorem? Explain.
D. What practical problem do courts run into when imposing damages in situations like this?
Expert Solution
This question has been solved!
Explore an expertly crafted, step-by-step solution for a thorough understanding of key concepts.
This is a popular solution!
Trending now
This is a popular solution!
Step by step
Solved in 5 steps
Knowledge Booster
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, accounting and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.Recommended textbooks for you
Business Its Legal Ethical & Global Environment
Accounting
ISBN:
9781305224414
Author:
JENNINGS
Publisher:
Cengage
Business Its Legal Ethical & Global Environment
Accounting
ISBN:
9781305224414
Author:
JENNINGS
Publisher:
Cengage
Individual Income Taxes
Accounting
ISBN:
9780357109731
Author:
Hoffman
Publisher:
CENGAGE LEARNING - CONSIGNMENT