Prove that carnot engine efficiency can never be one

Physical Chemistry
2nd Edition
ISBN:9781133958437
Author:Ball, David W. (david Warren), BAER, Tomas
Publisher:Ball, David W. (david Warren), BAER, Tomas
Chapter3: The Second And Third Laws Of Thermodynamics
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 3.7E
icon
Related questions
Question
100%

Prove that carnot engine efficiency can never be one

Expert Solution
Step 1

Carnot heat engine is a theoretical engine which operates between two temperatures on a Carnot cycle.

It helps in converting the heat into work with maximum possible efficiency possible 

The cycle involves 4 reversible process which are 

1) Isothermal expansion

2) Adiabatic expansion 

3) Isothermal compression 

4) Adiabatic compression 

Step 2

The P v/s V cycle for a Carnot heat engine looks like as shown below

Chemistry homework question answer, step 2, image 1

Step 3

The necessary thermodynamic quantities involved in each step are 

1) process (1-2) i.e Isothermal Expansion : Since the process is isothermal => Temperature is constant 

hence internal energy change is 0 

=> QH = -W = nRTH X ln(V2 / V1 ) 

where QH = heat of the process, W = work 

n = moles of gas, R = gas constant and TH = hot reservoir temperature 

V2 = final volume after expansion and V1 = initial volume before expansion 

Step 4

2) process (2-3) i.e Adiabatic Expansion : Since the process is Adiabatic => Q = 0

=> W = ΔU = nCvΔT

where ΔU  = change in internal energy , W = work 

n = moles of gas, Cv = specific heat for the gas and ΔT = change in temperature = TL - TH 

TH = hot reservoir temperature and TL = cold reservoir temperature 

steps

Step by step

Solved in 7 steps with 1 images

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Thermodynamics
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, chemistry and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Physical Chemistry
Physical Chemistry
Chemistry
ISBN:
9781133958437
Author:
Ball, David W. (david Warren), BAER, Tomas
Publisher:
Wadsworth Cengage Learning,
Principles of Modern Chemistry
Principles of Modern Chemistry
Chemistry
ISBN:
9781305079113
Author:
David W. Oxtoby, H. Pat Gillis, Laurie J. Butler
Publisher:
Cengage Learning