Assignment 4 ANTR2005

.docx

School

Laurentian University *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

2005

Subject

Anthropology

Date

Apr 3, 2024

Type

docx

Pages

5

Uploaded by ElderWorld10307

Report
Assignment 4 Department of Anthropology, Laurentian University ANTR2005, Child Rearing Across Cultures January 26, 2024
1. Based on the required videos and readings, outline the nurture versus nature controversy between Margaret Mead and Derek Freeman. (5 marks) Margaret Mead became wildly know for her anthropological theory surrounding the controversy of nature versus nurture. Mead was chosen by her professor to study adolescents in Samoa (Ferguson, 2024). The findings in Mead’s study were found to prove nurture over nature as she states the stresses are of adolescent girls are different in comparison to their American counterparts (Mead and Samoa, 1988). Mead’s final findings suggested that the behaviour of adolescent girls was dependent on the culture surroundings (Mead and Samoa, 1988). Through personal studies, Derek Freeman began to see holes in Mead’s study and believes that Mead was deceived by the Samoan community (Freeman, 1983). This study challenged Mead’s findings and attempts to prove unethical gathering of information (Mead and Samoa, 1988). Freeman explained through his studies that Mead did not immerse herself into the community, and lived with American Samoans, and obtained the majority of her information from selected informants (Freeman, 1983). Freeman suggests that Mead’s advisor in studying had a very strong connection to nurturing approaches to anthropological studies of human development (Freeman, 1983). This would mean that Freeman is insinuating that Mead’s approach to her study was biased to nurture over nature to begin with. He also explains that through his studies, he received information from his allies that debunked Mead’s findings, especially inclusive to the sexual patterns of Samoan adolescents (Freeman, 1983). Mead suggests that sexual behaviour before marriage was both unacceptable and also quite normalized, whereas Freeman found that Samoan culture did not approve of sexual behaviour prior to marriage (Freeman, 1983). Freeman was able to conclude from his information that informants of Mead’s were likely providing her false information to tease her (Freeman, 1983).
Free was able to find that although very far apart, both Samoan and American adolescent girls had very similar experiences of maturation (Freeman, 1983). Freeman’s reports started a controversary in the Anthropology field and his suggestions of Mead’s studies being false stirred up immense drama. 2. Based on the required videos and readings, outline and explain the Amish rite of passage known as “Rumspringa.” Illustrate how this rite of passage follows Arnold van Gennep’s three stages. (5 marks) Arnold Van Gennep has said that the three stage of the rite of passage are separation, transition and reincorporation (Herdt, 2006). The Amish community allows their youth to participate in a rite of passage tradition called rumspringa, which loosely translate to running around (Outsiders, 2009). This ritual allows for youth at the age of 16 to explore the world of the “English” before deciding to be baptized and fully accept the Amish way of life (Ferguson, 2024). The Amish way of life is quite strict, as founded by Jacob Ammann, it has not changed much since the 16 th century (Ferguson, 2024). Ammann enforced rules that encompassed dress, hygeine, grooming, and living styles (Ferguson, 2024). Throughout rumspringa, the young people are separated from their community, and their family and community turn a blind eye to their actions. While some of the young people continue to live in their communities, many choose to leave and fully experience the English world to the full capacity (Outsiders, 2009). While through rumspringa the youth are able to communicate with their families, but understand that the choices and actions being go against all that was learned growing up. This is distinctive to the first step of separation in the rite of passage theory as explained by Van Gennep, and proves his theory (Herdt, 2006). This step allows for the youth to understand what their lives could feel like, beyond the Amish community. From age 16 onward, this period is a
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
  • Access to all documents
  • Unlimited textbook solutions
  • 24/7 expert homework help