Peer Review Outline
.docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Arizona State University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
301
Subject
English
Date
Dec 6, 2023
Type
docx
Pages
2
Uploaded by CountFang11411
Problem Statement:
The writer has identified a significant issue at Arizona State University, where approximately
14% of the waste generated on campus consists of single-use plastic, particularly plastic water
bottles. The problem extends beyond campus boundaries, contributing to environmental issues
like overflowing landfills.
Proposed Solution:
The writer proposes to phase out single-use plastic water bottles at Arizona State University by
transitioning to glass bottles, aluminum cans, and emphasizing the use of refill stations. The
solution involves vendor selection, promoting sustainable practices, and a phased elimination of
single-use plastic waste.
Purpose Statement:
Yes, the proposal includes a purpose statement at the beginning. The purpose is to advocate for a
sustainable shift on the ASU campus by eliminating plastic water bottles, aligning with ASU’s
commitment to environmental responsibility and innovation.
Organization:
The proposal is generally well-organized. It introduces the purpose, presents the problem,
discusses the environmental impact, proposes solutions, and concludes with a summary.
However, the writer could improve the transition between sections for a smoother flow.
Effectiveness of Problem Explanation:
The writer effectively communicates the problem of plastic waste, supported by statistics and
information from ASU's data. However, the correlation between mental health and counseling
services, while mentioned in your feedback, is not a part of this proposal. It seems there might be
some confusion or a reference to a different context.
Specificity of Proposed Solution:
The proposed solution is specific, breaking down the transition into a four-step process and
providing details on each step. It suggests concrete actions like vendor selection, promotion of
sustainable practices, and phased elimination.
Logical and Feasible Solution:
The proposed solution appears logical and feasible, addressing environmental concerns and
aligning with ASU’s sustainability goals. However, potential objections related to budgeting and
the high turnover rate in counseling services are not explicitly addressed.
Clarity of Parts or Steps:
The proposal includes a numbered list with explanations for each point, making the steps clear
and well-structured.
Anticipation of Objections:
While the proposal presents various statistics and information, it may not adequately address
potential objections, especially concerning budget constraints and the turnover rate in counseling
services.
Additional Sections:
A cost section detailing the budget for the proposed solution would enhance the proposal,
considering the potential financial implications. This would provide a more comprehensive
understanding of the feasibility of the proposed changes.
More Evidence and Cost Breakdown:
The proposal could benefit from more evidence establishing the correlation between mental
health and counseling services. Additionally, breaking down the budget for the proposed solution
would add depth and transparency.
Formatting:
The formatting is not mentioned in the feedback, but you note that removing indentations will
improve it. Ensuring full-left block text will enhance the overall presentation.
Use of Headings:
The proposal correctly includes headings, aiding in the organization and clarity of different
sections.
Grammar and Punctuation:
The grammar and punctuation are correct, contributing to the overall professionalism of the
proposal.
Additional Feedback:
Consider addressing potential objections related to budgeting and counselor turnover explicitly.
Providing more evidence for the correlation between mental health and counseling services
would strengthen the proposal. Also, a clear cost breakdown would enhance the transparency of
the proposed solution's financial implications.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help