Copy%20of%20Copy%20of%20OPCVL%20Source%20Evaluation%20Template%20(B-CC%202023-24

.pdf

School

University of Houston *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

4322

Subject

English

Date

Jan 9, 2024

Type

pdf

Pages

Uploaded by AmbassadorGoose3406

Source #1 Author(s): Jillian Schneider Name of source: Read Lion Publication/Publisher of source: The Herzog Foundation Date of Source: 11/16/23 URL or Name of Database: https://readlion.com/montgomery-county-public-schools-faces-first-amendment-lawsui t-from-parents-who-want-ability-to-opt-out/ Origin: Who created the source? What do you know about the author/creator, either from the source or googling for more info? What “authority” (credentials, qualifications) does the author/creator have? Is this a primary or secondary source? When was it created and is the info still accurate or relevant? The source is created by Jillian Schneider, a Christian staff writer who also writes for the right-wing outlet "The Federalist." The source is published by the Herzog Foundation, a Christian-based educational non-profit organization. Knowing the background of the author and the publication suggests a potential bias towards a Christian and conservative perspective. Purpose: Why was this source created? To advertise? To entertain? To sell? To persuade? To educate and inform? Who is the intended audience? The source aims to inform the readers about the ongoing lawsuit and the allegations made by America First Legal against Montgomery County Public Schools in Maryland. The intended audience might be individuals interested in education and legal matters. Content: What new information did you gain from this source? What is the message of the source? What information or examples does the author use to support their point? The content of the source provides information about the lawsuit, including the claims made by America First Legal, objections from parents regarding the inclusion of LGBT books in MCPS classrooms, restrictions on public meeting attendance, and allegations of blocking social media access. It highlights the viewpoints and actions of the defendants and the objections raised by the plaintiffs. Value: How will the source’s information help you with your project? What background knowledge about your topic does this provide and how will it help you with your project? This source provides information about the specific claims made in the lawsuit against Montgomery County Public Schools. It offers insights into the controversy surrounding the inclusion of LGBT books in classrooms and the objections raised by parents. It can help in understanding the perspectives and arguments of the parties involved in the lawsuit. Limitation: Is it biased? How reliable is the site or company publishing this content? What information was not available to the author when it was created? Was information specifically left out or intentionally emphasized? How does historical context inﬂuence your interpretation?

The source is published by the Herzog Foundation, a Christian-based educational non-profit organization, and written by Jillian Schneider, a staff writer who also contributes to the right-wing outlet "The Federalist." This suggests a potential bias towards a Christian and conservative perspective. The information presented is likely inﬂuenced by these ideological leanings and may not provide a comprehensive or balanced view of the issue. Source #2 Author(s): Olivia Land Name of source: New York Post Publication/Publisher of source: New York Post Date of Source: August 25, 2023 URL or Name of Database: https://nypost.com/2023/08/25/maryland-court-rules-that-parents-cant-opt-out-of-in clusivity/ Origin: Who created the source? What do you know about the author/creator, either from the source or googling for more info? What “authority” (credentials, qualifications) does the author/creator have? Is this a primary or secondary source? When was it created and is the info still accurate or relevant? The author of this source is Olivia Land, a long-time writer for the New York Post. The source was published by the New York Post on August 25, 2023. The New York Post is a well-known newspaper. While the author's credentials are not explicitly provided, it can be assumed that she has experience in journalism. Purpose: Why was this source created? To advertise? To entertain? To sell? To persuade? To educate and inform? Who is the intended audience? The purpose of this source is to report on a Maryland court ruling regarding parents' ability to opt their children out of lessons featuring inclusive LGBTQ+ books on religious grounds. The article aims to inform readers about the court's decision and the arguments made by both sides. The intended audience is likely the general readership of the New York Post. Content: What new information did you gain from this source? What is the message of the source? What information or examples does the author use to support their point? The source discusses a lawsuit filed by three families from Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS) seeking to reinstate a district policy that would allow them to remove their children from lessons with inclusive LGBTQ+ books due to religious objections. The court denied the parents' request for a preliminary injunction, stating that their right to shape their children's education according to their religious practices was not a "fundamental right." The article includes quotes from the judge's decision, highlighting the benefits of inclusive curriculums and the argument that the policy does not force parents to violate their religious beliefs. Value: How will the source’s information help you with your project? What background knowledge about your topic does this provide and how will it help you with your project?

This source provides information on a recent court ruling and the ongoing controversy surrounding parents' ability to opt their children out of LGBTQ+ inclusive lessons in Montgomery County Public Schools. It offers insights into the arguments made by the parents, the judge's reasoning for denying the preliminary injunction, and the benefits of inclusive curriculums. This information can contribute to understanding the legal and societal implications of the court's decision and its impact on the rights of parents and the education system. Limitation: Is it biased? How reliable is the site or company publishing this content? What information was not available to the author when it was created? Was information specifically left out or intentionally emphasized? How does historical context inﬂuence your interpretation? The limitation of this source is that the author's credentials beyond being a long-time writer for the New York Post are not provided. This makes it difficult to assess the author's expertise on the subject. Additionally, as a newspaper, the New York Post has its own editorial biases that inﬂuence the presentation of the information. Source #3 Author(s): Ida Domingo Name of source: ABC 7 Publication/Publisher of source: ABC 7 Date of Source: August 24, 2023 URL or Name of Database: https://wjla.com/news/crisis-in-the-classrooms/montgomery-county-schools-parents-r ally-policy-lgbtq-plus-books-cirriculum-court-mcps-superintendent-mcknight-school-bo ard-decision-religious-rights-muslim-catholic-ethiopian-orthodox-maryland-education Origin: Who created the source? What do you know about the author/creator, either from the source or googling for more info? What “authority” (credentials, qualifications) does the author/creator have? Is this a primary or secondary source? When was it created and is the info still accurate or relevant? The author of this source is Ida Domingo, and the source is published by ABC 7. ABC 7 is a reputable news organization. While no further information about the author's credentials is given, it can be assumed that she is a journalist with experience in reporting news. Purpose: Why was this source created? To advertise? To entertain? To sell? To persuade? To educate and inform? Who is the intended audience? he purpose of this source is to report on the upcoming oral arguments in a lawsuit seeking an opt-out option for LGBTQ+ storybooks in Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS). The article aims to inform readers about the lawsuit, the arguments made by the parents, and the scheduled hearing. The intended audience is likely the general readership of ABC 7. Content: What new information did you gain from this source? What is the message of the source? What information or examples does the author use to support their point?

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help